'A Woman Is a Woman'
Go-go Godard
TO SUM UP the plot (apply the term loosely here) of Jean-Luc
Godard's third feature film is easy enough: A stripper (Godard's wife
and muse, Anna Karina) decides out of the blue that she wants to have
a baby. Her husband (Jean-Claude Brialy) isn't ready to father a child,
so he enlists his best friend (Jean-Paul Belmondo) to do the deed. To
attempt to describe the sheer giddiness this giggle-inducing deconstruction
will induce in viewers, however, is a wee bit harder. Rather than dipping
his toe into the avant-garde, the Gallic wunderkind dove in headfirst
by dismantling musical conventions one by one: bits of swirling scores
blast in and out at random then drop into silence, song lyrics are mostly
spoken straight as dialogue, and dance numbers are choreographed
as freeze-frames. Yet even as it morphs into a dense look at what happens
when the unreality of the spectacle gets injected with nouvelle vague
rawness, Godard still manages to keep things breezy, goofy, and soufflé-lite.
For him, a woman may simply be a woman, as the title implies, but a
film is never simply a film: it's also a love letter, a manifesto, a
poem, a prank, a journal, a forum, a house of cards to be knocked down,
and a hall of mirrors (Belmondo, named "Alfred Lubitsch,"
wants to get home early since "Breathless is on TV";
at one point Jeanne Moreau shows up and is asked how the in-progress
Jules et Jim shoot is going). Godard claimed he'd set out to
film a romantic comedy using the grammar of melodrama; later he humbly
admitted, "I don't know whether it's a comedy or a tragedy. At
any rate, it's a masterpiece." You'll get no argument from me.
(David Fear)