The dirt in D6

Daly hit with stealthy attacks linked to the mentor of his main opponent
|
()

amanda@sfbg.comsarah@sfbg.com If you live in San Francisco's District 6, it's pretty difficult to avoid what some residents are calling a new filth polluting Tenderloin corners and SoMa streets. It's not overflowing trash bins or urine-stained door frames — it's the relentless election billeting that uses those images to support Rob Black and oppose Chris Daly for the district's seat on the Board of Supervisors. "We're tired of talk. Of loud, whining, condescending, offensive, abusive, lying, showcasing, arrogant talk," reads a recent poster on a telephone pole. "District 6 is dirty and dangerous. District 6 is still poor. Chris Daly is why. Dump Daly. Back Rob Black." "I was totally offended by this," Debra Walker, a progressive activist and resident of the district for 25 years, told the Guardian. "This kind of message intentionally suppresses the vote. People I've talked to in the district who aren't very political are totally turned off by the mailings from Rob Black or made in his benefit." Some of the mailings, posters, and literature can be directly attributed to independent expenditure (IE) committees recognized by the Ethics Commission and acting legally. Some, however, have more dubious ancestry but apparent links to a campaign attorney with a long history of using millions to control the outcome of elections in San Francisco: Jim Sutton (see "The Political Puppeteer," 2/4/04). Sutton did not return calls for comment. Most of the anonymous literature directs people to the Web site www.DumpDaly.org. SFSOS's Wade Randlett told us his group paid for the site and a volunteer set it up. SFSOS and Sutton formed Citizens for Reform Leadership 1–6 — IE committees listed on many of the signs and much of the literature, including the poster quoted above. The committees haven't filed any IE reports with the Ethics Commission. Walker, along with Maria Guillen, vice president of SEIU Local 790, and another District 6 resident, Jim Meko, submitted a complaint with the Ethics Commission on Sept. 29 with nine pieces of physical evidence supporting their concern that the roof had been blown off the $83,000 spending cap on the campaign, in place because all candidates agreed to public financing. The evidence submitted with the complaint varied and included three different mailers from "Concerned Residents of District 6," a committee that has yet to exist on paper in the Ethics Commission filing cabinets. The mailers from the "Concerned Residents" are glossy triptychs critical of Daly but not explicitly advocating for another candidate. They do not state the amount the committee paid for them, which is required of any electioneering communication. On Oct. 6 the Ethics Commission released a statement saying the spending cap for District 6 was no longer in effect. John St. Croix, executive director of the commission, has identified at least $90,000 in IEs, including three unreported mailers. "At some point we will attempt to determine who distributed the mailers," St. Croix said. "But it's not likely before the election." The tactic of breaking the law before the election and taking the heat after the ballots are in has been used in the past, and this new example flouts recently passed legislation. These mailings should have been filed with the Ethics Commission, according to an ordinance passed in 2005 in response to similar anonymous hit pieces that came out in the elections of 2003 and 2004 against Supervisors Gerardo Sandoval and Jake McGoldrick. (Sutton defended SFSOS's main funder, Donald Fisher, in his successful Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation against Sandoval over the issue.) "It's a strategy taken straight from Karl Rove's playbook," Meko, a 30-year SoMa resident, told us. Joe Lynn, former Ethics Commission member and staffer, told us "all the committees in San Francisco should turn their backs on contributions from people who are involved in this scheme — at least until they explain their involvement.

Also from this author

  • Local Heroes

    Best of the Bay 2008

  • Dark days

    Why is it so hard to get solar power in San Francisco?

  • Proposition 90 isn't about eminent domain