Parsing the homophobia of "UR So Gay"


SONIC REDUCER Does post-postirony still really translate as ... irony? Or does any freaking thing matter at all, because the smirking, snarky '80s are so very back that we're backpedaling madly in our kooky plastic-and-who-really-cares-about-that-legendary-flotilla-of-plastic-in-the-Pacific-Ocean kiddie pool with what-the-hell carelessness, basking in apathy and gloss? Does that mean we're ready to embrace our inner bigot? The jerkiest, knee-jerk reactionary responses from back in Grandpappy's day, namely the Ronald Reagan era? Can our dingiest backward notions give us edge cred, convince us that we're getting down as hard as those bad boys and girls of Vice et al., and provide fodder for schoolyard taunts, barroom brawls, dirty limericks, and — sweet — even songs? Aw, you're so cute when you're smug as a bug.

It's hard to know what to think or feel or which cheek to plunge one's tongue into while listening to Katy Perry's "UR So Gay," off her self-titled digital EP and 12-inch (Capitol). Amazement or repulsion? Gay bashing in song can get as overt and stomach turning as Jamaica's so-called murder music: see Buju Banton's entreaties, on "Boom Bye Bye," to shoot gay men in the head and burn them alive. But it's hard to parse the goofy novelty of "UR So Gay": it rides the new wave deca-dance rail between mild offense — for metrosexuals, gay straight men, gay men who want to own the word gay, and folks in favor of good music — and milky outrage. Has there been such a borderline-bashing Cali pop case since Josie Cotton's 1980 "Johnny Are You Queer"? The Rizzo look-alike spun '50s girl group tearjerker motifs — from the True Romance–style single cover art to her nyah-nyah-wah-wah plaintive bad-girl character's delivery. "Why are you so weird, boy? / Johnny, are you queer boy? / When I make a play / You're pushing me away," Cotton pouts. Oh, the perils of falling for someone who doesn't flog for you — and never will. The conflicted "Johnny" hinged on tweaking the highly codified conventions of '60s pop and doing the dirty by speaking the unspoken, even as an undercurrent of rage from a straight woman scorned surged beneath the number's carefree contours.

In contrast, the blogged 'n' buzzed "UR So Gay" — riding on word of mouth for the woman who told me, "My mouth never shuts up, unfortunately" — references pop history, filtered somewhat through the '80s, in Perry's Cyndi Lauper–esque prom-queen styling. Apart from displaying a thick vein of social conservatism that disapproves of a metrosexual muddying of waters, songwriter Perry purveys all-'90s pop, swamped with an over-the-top arrangement, as the track's heroine slags her ex: "I hope you hang yourself with your H&M scarf / While jacking off listening to Mozart / You bitch and moan about LA / Wishing you were in the rain reading Hemingway / You don't eat meat / And drive electric cars / You're so indie rock it's almost an art / You need SPF 45 just to stay alive. You're so gay and you don't even like boys.... I can't believe I fell in love with someone that wears more makeup than ..."

Perry's litany of insults, backed by a loping, going-nowhere beat, isn't stereotypically gay — doit, what self-respecting stylish homosexual swain would get stuck on Mozart, Hemingway, and H&M? If anything, the list reveals the general throwaway nature of the tune and the cluelessness of the singer. Nonetheless, the "you're so gay" chorus rankles, ever so softly, ever so wispily homophobically, in the way it detaches gayness from sexuality and attaches it firmly to notions of pretension, aloofness, and inaccessibility — under the guise of harmless good fun and quasi truth telling.

Also from this author

  • Women with movie cameras

    Cheers to CAAMFest's crop of female Asian American film directors

  • Spiking the box office

    THE YEAR IN FILM: Looking back at a triumphant year for African American films

  • Not from around here

    French synth-pop giants Phoenix and Daft Punk tap into the alien within

  • Also in this section

  • Peace-out

    After seven rockin' years, Sonic Reducer bids adieu with a look back at some choice musical moments

  • Feel the 'Love

    Rosily buzzing U.K. outfit the Big Pink gets it, Carly Simon and all

  • Sly 'n' sincere

    Don't confuse this Brit with Britney. Plus: Midlake and Barn Owl and Daniel Higgs