SAN FRANCISCO RACES
Board of Supervisors
The incumbent District 1 supervisor, Jake McGoldrick, likes to joke that he holds his seat only because Eric Mar's house burned down eight years ago. Back then Mar, who has had a stellar career on the school board, decided to wait before seeking higher office.
But now McGoldrick overall a good supervisor who was wrong on a few key votes is termed out, and progressive San Francisco is pretty much unanimous in supporting Mar as his successor.
Mar, a soft-spoken San Francisco State University teacher, was a strong critic of former school superintendent Arlene Ackerman and a leader in the battle to get the somewhat dictatorial and autocratic administrator out of the district. He's been a key part of the progressive majority that's made substantial progress in improving the San Francisco public schools.
He's a perfect candidate for District 1. He has strong ties to the district and its heavily Asian population. He's a sensible progressive with solid stands on the key issues and a proven ability to get things done. He supports the affordable housing measure, Proposition B; the Clean Energy Act, Proposition H; and the major new revenue measures. He's sensitive to tenant issues, understands the need for a profound new approach to affordable housing, and wants to solve the city's structural budget problems with new revenue, not just cuts.
His chief opponent, Sue Lee, who works for the Chamber of Commerce, doesn't support Prop. H and won't even commit to supporting district elections. She ducked a lot of our questions and was either intentionally vague or really has no idea what she would do as a supervisor. She's no choice for the district, and we found no other credible candidates worthy of our endorsement. Vote for Eric Mar.
1. DAVID CHIU
2. DENISE MCCARTHY
3. TONY GANTNER
The danger in this district is Joe Alioto. He's smooth, he's slick, he's well funded and he would be a disaster for San Francisco. Make no mistake about it, Alioto is the candidate of downtown and thanks to his famous name and wads of big-business cash, he's a serious contender.
Two progressive candidates have a chance at winning this seat and keeping Alioto off the board. David Chiu is a member of the Small Business Commission (SBC) and the Democratic County Central Committee (DCCC) and is a former civil rights lawyer who now manages a company that sells campaign software. Denise McCarthy ran the Telegraph Hill Neighborhood Center for 25 years and spent 7 years on the Port Commission.
Tony Gantner, a retired lawyer, is also in the race, although he is running well behind the others in the polls.
We have concerns about all the candidates. Chiu has a solid progressive record as a commissioner and committee member: He was one of only two SBC members who supported the living-wage ordinance and Sup. Tom Ammiano's city health care plan. He backed Sup. Aaron Peskin, his political mentor, for chair of the DCCC. He backs Prop. H, supports the two revenue measures and the affordable-housing fund, and wants to give local small businesses a leg up in winning city contracts. He has some creative ideas about housing, including a community stabilization fee on new development.
He's also a partner in a company that received $143,000 last year from PG&E and that has worked with Republicans and some nasty business interests.
Chiu says he doesn't get to call all the shots at Grassroots Enterprises, which he cofounded.