SUPERIOR COURT JUDGE, SEAT 6
It's rare to see an open seat on the Superior Court; judges typically retire midterm and allow the governor to appoint their replacement. And with a Republican governor, the more progressive Democrats have had a hard time getting even close to judicial appointments. Four highly qualified candidates are seeking this seat, and all of them make good cases for election.
Since judicial candidates can't take stands on most political issues or indicate how they might rule on cases, it's hard to get a sense of where the candidates stand. But they can talk about their backgrounds and experience — and about how the local courts are run. For example, the Superior Court is managed on a day-to-day basis by a presiding judge, elected by the sitting judges on the San Francisco bench. But those elections are secret; nobody except the judges know who the candidates were; who voted for which one; or what the final tally was. Court administration is done in closed meetings. Most of what happens in the courts is public — but there's no presumption of cameras in the courtrooms to give the public access to the justice system.
Our choices for judge reflect our interest in a diverse judiciary, judges who have both professional and personal experience that will shape fair decisions — and jurists who believe in open government, including open courts.
Our choice for Seat 6 is Linda Colfax, a deputy public defender with a background in community service (she's been an ACLU board member) and progressive politics. Like all four candidates, she has impressive legal credentials and trial experience. She also strongly supports sunshine in the courts and told us she would allow the press and public into judges' meetings when appropriate, supports cameras in the courtrooms (except for cases where a witness or crime victim has to be protected), and efforts to make the courts work more efficiently.
Robert Retana, who grew up in East Los Angeles, has worked in both civil and criminal law, as a prosecutor and a civil litigator. He also has extensive community service with La Raza Centro Legal and the Lawyer's Committee for Civil Rights. He was awfully vague on cameras in the courtroom and didn't seem well-informed on open-government issues, but he's certainly qualified for the job.
Rod Mcleod, a former San Francisco School Board member, told us he won't raise any money for this race since he thinks judges shouldn't be captive to special interests. That's noble, but it also makes it unlikely he'll be a factor in the end.
Harry Dorfman, a career prosecutor with the District Attorney's Office, has extensive trial experience but was the least willing of all the candidates we interviewed to expand public access to the courts.
Colfax has the endorsements of Assembly Member Tom Ammiano, Sen. Mark Leno, and Sups. David Campos, John Avalos, and Eric Mar, among others. She would also diversify the bench in a significant way, not just because she's a lesbian but because she spent her career in the Public Defender's Office. And since Democratic and Republican governors alike tend not to appoint public defenders to the bench, that background and perspective is rare. Vote for Colfax.
SUPERIOR COURT JUDGE, SEAT 15
Another rarity here: a contested race where challengers are taking on a sitting judge. Richard Ulmer, the incumbent, was a Republican living in Hillsborough when Gov. Schwarzenegger appointed him to the bench last year; he quickly changed his registration to independent and took up residence in Park Merced.
Most Commented On
- BS, the "people" are - March 14, 2014
- Can anyone point out any - March 14, 2014
- mmmkay - March 14, 2014
- COURT FIGHT BEGINNING MARCH 17 IS ABOUT MORE THAN THE WATERFRONT - March 14, 2014
- Most people who hang at 16th - March 14, 2014
- And maybe... - March 14, 2014
- Steven's still pretty sexy - March 14, 2014
- Steve has never lost his "sex, drugs and rock'n'roll" alter ego - March 14, 2014
- Exactly, Guest - March 14, 2014
- Of course, SFBG won't stop whining - March 14, 2014