Debt-defying futures

CAREERS AND ED ISSUE: It's not easy to escape the student loan — but there are ways


CAREERS AND ED Student loans are a very special kind of debt. Like an armored car or an airplane's black box, they are practically indestructible. While a person could sign up for a credit card, max it out on luxury items, and then wriggle off the hook of repayment by filing for bankruptcy, this escape hatch is blocked when it comes to taking out a nondischargeable student loan. Like tattoos, they stick to a borrower for life — or at least, until they are repaid.

"It's almost impossible to discharge this debt in bankruptcy," says Edie Irons, communications director for Oakland-based The Institute for College Access and Success (TICAS). "When you make that investment in a home, you have collateral, and you can use that asset. But when you invest in education, it's not a guarantee. And if you can't make those payments, the cost of collection can be pretty dear. They can garnish your wages. They can take your Social Security, your tax refunds. For federal loans, they have a lot of pretty scary powers of collection."

Fortunately for those borrowers facing insurmountable debt, a few options (aside from feigning one's own death) do exist for reducing, if not eliminating, the burden of student loans.

Volunteer opportunities through AmeriCorps, the Peace Corps, and Volunteers in Service to America (VISTA) provide stipends and money that can be put toward loan repayment in exchange for service. Graduates who serve through AmeriCorps ( for one year can receive up to $7,400 in stipends plus $4,725 toward loan repayment. Peace Corps volunteers can apply for deferment of Stafford, Perkins, and consolidation loans, and may receive cancellation of their Perkins Loans at a rate of 15 percent per year. Graduates volunteering with a nonprofit through VISTA can receive $4,725 for 1,700 hours of service.

Students who opt to become teachers in elementary or secondary schools serving students from low-income families can have portions of their Perkins Loan forgiven at increasing rates over the first five years of teaching, and members of the Teach for America corps program are eligible to receive a $5,350 award for each year of teaching plus postponed loan repayment with interest paid.

Two recently created programs also broaden the options for graduates facing insurmountable loan debt. The federal Income-Based Repayment (IBR) program is a new payment option for federal loans for borrowers who have enough debt relative to income to qualify for a reduced payment. Borrowers who earn less than 150 percent of the poverty level (that's $16,245 for an individual) pay nothing; those who earn more can have loan payments capped at 15 percent of whatever they earn above that amount and forgiven entirely after 25 years of payments.

The Public Service Loan Forgiveness programs offer debt forgiveness for graduates entering certain fields. According to the program website (, eligible borrowers are people employed in nonprofit, 501(c)(3) organizations and people who work for federal, state, local, or tribal government. The program forgives remaining student loan debt on most federal loans after 10 years of eligible employment and qualifying loan payments. Law students entering public service can learn more about this program and others through Equal Justice Works (

While these options may offer a boost for borrowers with federal student loans, those with private loan debt may not be as lucky. Irons notes that TICAS is engaged in efforts to encourage legislators in Washington to consider treating private loans "more like other consumer debt rather than this extra harsh treatment."

"We want to see that changed," she said. "People who are playing by the rules shouldn't be punished when things go horribly wrong for them. Right now, there's almost no way out of private loan debt."


It's like a sentence as if you did something wrong. the government needs to understand that when a college offers a certain degree to 1000 people, while being fully aware that only 20 jobs are available, these people deserve to get some sort of debt reduction because of the college's clear attempt to make money rather than provide higher education. While I was in my second year, professors were openly saying that we have absolutely no chance at getting hired within our field because the field is already dead. How can they keep making people pay for these degree when they know they are worthless?
You mentioned the difference that you can discharge credit card debt. I didn't discharge mine, I paid a part of it through a settlement ( because I wasn't able to pay it back for months after graduation.
I will definitely look into the options you listed above but I can't imagine that the government will simply sit back and let educational institutions sell their worthless degrees as if "providing student the choice of learning what they love to do".

Posted by Jessica Lawrence on Nov. 22, 2011 @ 5:09 pm

didn't investigate your degree and listen to your professors?

Is this post supposed to be ironic? Is this post by someone mocking the entitlement attitude of certain segments of the population. How could anyone seriously post this that is over 12? Who is "they" the people that let you finance your college education in what you wanted to take?

If not irony, what was "the government" supposed to do as you rode the rails into a useless degree, would you be bitching about the government crushing your dream to have a inuit studies degree now?

Posted by Matlock on Nov. 22, 2011 @ 5:34 pm

...has been sitting back for decades allowing all manner of 'institutions' to sell worthless snake oil 'concoctions' to trusting individuals who still believe that the 'government' is dedicated to the best interests of the people, and that 'they' are protecting, serving and upholding the Constitution and Bill of Rights.
Hang in there.
Good luck.
Occupy Reality.
Don't get fooled again.

Posted by Patrick Monk. RN on Nov. 22, 2011 @ 5:38 pm

You step on the nail, it's the government's fault.

The wing blew up and I got sand in my eyes, governments fault.

You take a degree in something that is a career ghetto, it's the governments fault.

What a strange conflation of paranoid government ravings there Patrick, the government allows a person to get loans for all sorts of goofy degrees and accredits herbology colleges. It's the governments fault that a person takes those degrees according to Mr Monk. A person is smart enough to get through a studies degree by agreeing with the teacher's opinions consistently, but they are not smart enough to do a little research on their own, so it's "the governments" fault?

On the flip side if "the government" said, we have a surplus of various under employed studies grads and thus, "the government" decides to stop allowing loans to these degrees you would howl about that too. There is only so many cities that will elect a John Avalos.

Posted by guest on Nov. 22, 2011 @ 6:03 pm

Related articles

  • Faces of debt

    CAREERS AND ED ISSUE: For these three students, debt from attending California schools will affect their lives for years to come

  • Local bounty

    CAREERS AND ED ISSUE: From monkeyface eel fishing to wild mushroom forays -- classes to clue you in on your surroundings

  • Revolution 101

    CAREERS AND ED ISSUE: Free University of San Francisco takes a run at the system