Drawing a line in the toxic triangle - Page 3

Advocates mount a regional push for environmental justice


So the Coalition for Clean and Safe Ports, which pushed for tougher air-quality regulations, is now pressuring for a reform of the trucking industry to place the cost of clean upgrades onto powerful trucking companies instead of low-wage drivers. The coalition's campaign has sought to link the needs of the drivers and the surrounding community, organizing rallies with blue-green signs bearing the motto "Good Jobs & Clean Air" to call for a change to the truckers' employment classification from independent contractors to employees, which would shift the cost of compliance onto employers instead of drivers.

West Oakland isn't the only East Bay area inflicted by excessive levels of diesel particulate matter from trucks entering the Port of Oakland. The fumes also affect East Oakland neighborhoods bisected by the big rigs' primary thoroughfares. In addition to truck traffic and freeways, East Oakland is also the site of numerous hazardous-waste handlers and abandoned industrial sites.

Nehanda Imara, an organizer with CBE who also helped put together the Toxic Triangle Coalition forums, described how her organization recruited volunteers to count the number of trucks passing through a heavily traveled East Oakland strip as a way to quantify the source of particulate matter pollution. They reached a tally of around 11,700 over the course of 10 days.

Some progress has been made to limit the exposure of diesel pollution for East Oakland residents. The city is working on a comprehensive plan to assess trucking routes, and a campaign to limit truck idling is helping to limit unnecessary tailpipe emissions.

Yet youth hospitalizations for asthma in East Oakland are 150 percent to 200 percent higher than Alameda County taken as a whole, and an air-monitoring project in that area revealed high levels of particulate matter exceeding state and federal standards.

"That's also an environmental injustice," Imara said. "When the laws are there, but not being enforced."



In San Francisco's Bayview-Hunters Point neighborhood, environmental justice groups have spotlighted the toxic stew associated with the naval shipyard and other pollution sources for years. A 2004 report produced jointly by Greenaction for Health and Environmental Justice, the Bayview-Hunters Point Mothers Environmental Justice Committee, and the Huntersview Tenants Association outlined a "toxic inventory" of the area. The inventory depicts a more complicated web of toxic sources than the asbestos dust and naval shipyard cleanup that have been focal points of news coverage surrounding Lennar Corp.'s massive redevelopment plans for that neighborhood.

"Over half of the land in San Francisco that is zoned for industrial use is in Bayview-Hunters Point," this report noted. "The neighborhood is home to one federal Superfund site, the Hunters Point Naval Shipyard ... a sewage treatment plant that handles 80 percent of the city's solid wastes, 100 brownfield sites [a brownfield is an abandoned, idled, or underused commercial facility where expansion or redevelopment is limited because of environmental contamination], 187 leaking underground fuel tanks, and more than 124 hazardous waste handlers regulated by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency."

Related articles

  • Working on it

    Four California groups that are fighting for good, green jobs

  • It's not easy being green

    But our green resource guide is here to help

  • Threads of change

    A fibershed activist wants us to consider our clothes