The carnival-themed restaurant in Hayes Valley wins our teddy bear with playful plates

Cotton candy's got nothing on this fried chicken and waffle Monte Cristo sandwich.

We don't typically use the expression "start-up" when talking about restaurants — the phrase belongs to Techtopia and implies, at least to me, oceans of venture capital and huge salaries for people who run companies that don't make money. But if we did, Straw would be an ideal one. It's the sort of place one saw quite a few of in the early to mid 1990s, in that interval between the disasters of stock-market-crash-earthquake-war-fire and the start of the first tech boom. In that moment, people seemed to feel a renewed sense of optimism but didn't have pots of money. The result was a sequence of new restaurants offering superior food, high value, and modest (sometimes DIY) décor. If you couldn't afford to have Cass Calder Smith design your dining room, you could still somehow let it be known, through the medium of unprepossessingness, that you were reserving your best efforts for the food and service.

Straw, in this important sense, feels like a throwback from 1995. The restaurant (which opened in January) is small and slightly scruffy and is in an old building — a small oddity along Octavia Boulevard, which is newness itself and has been the occasion for all sorts of fresh construction in the past few years. The white walls, slightly scuffed, are hung with carnival posters, and some of the window seating seems to have been salvaged from a ride at a state fair somewhere. We haven't had a place like this in more than a decade, I don't think, not since the days when 3 Ring tried to make its circus theme fly in the old Val 21 space (now Dosa) on Valencia.

What kind of food would you expect to find at a carnival? Straw does provide some witty answers to this question, but the menu ranges gracefully beyond the obvious, which is to say the fried. Still, the fried stuff is good — a basket of little corn dogs ($7.75) made of Niman Ranch beef and looking like batter-fried musket balls. These were wonderfully crisp and juicy, and the trio of dipping sauces — nacho cheese, spicy ketchup, and ranch dressing — each had a strong enough personality to make them distinct, one from the others. The prawn ceviche ($7.75), boldly seasoned with habanero, lime, cilantro, and red pepper was presented in a fried tortilla cup, the kind tortilla salads come in, along with some tortilla chips on the side. These turned out to be good for dispensing with the last of the corndog sauces.

But not everything is fried, and the kitchen helps itself to a wide variety of influences. Grilled cobs of corn ($4) sprinkled with feta cheese, cayenne, and chili powder and presented with fresh lime and what the menu calls, with charming redundancy, "garlic aioli," seemed to have Mexican roots, while the mac 'n' cheese ($5), fortified with bacon and slices of apple (an excellent idea) was a nice little crock of Americana.

The menu is also vegetarian-friendly — and not just in the small dishes, though quite a few of those are meatless, among them the tomato soup, pretzel bites, and several of the salads. An entrée called samba on subuco ($12), festively joined chunks of butternut squash and eggplant in a slightly sweet (but not cloying) coconut-milk curry broth reminiscent of many a hormak talay in Thai restaurants. This dish succeeded for me, despite the eggplant, which managed to be both rubbery and mushy.

Places are found for flesh too, often cleverly. We were particularly impressed by the satchemo ($15), a bed of creamy white grits carefully inlaid with sautéed prawns, leaves of linguiça, and green filet beans. Apart from being flavorful and well-balanced, the dish was beautiful to look at: like a tile taken from the palace of an Ottoman pasha.


I love everything about Straw: the engaging decor, the wonderfully friendly staff (who seem to genuinely enjoy their work), and most of all the food. This review didn't mention several aspects that make me a regular diner there. (It helps that I live two blocks away---it's great to suddenly be so close to such a delicious restaurant!)

First, the food is cheap. I rarely order the entrees, most of which are about $15, because you can put together a feast based on the appetizers ($4-8 or so), the huge and varied salad (available in two sizes, usually for $6-9), and the sandwiches (the pulled pork hoagie-ish thing is amazing). It's also a great place for sharing food with friends, which helps mitigate any guilt you might feel for eating fried items.

Second, many dishes combine flavors that at first glance seem like they might not work, like a berry sauce (served on the side) with on the pork sandwich. Every combination I've tried has worked impressively.

They also have a great selection of unusual beers, will come get you in the coffee shop next door if it's crowded (which it often is) and there's a wait, and do fast, great takeout. One woman who works there (Naiomi) sometimes hugs me when I come in because she's seen ms so often and is just plain sweet.

I realize this review practically sounds like I'm an investor in the place or friends with the owners, but I'm honestly just thrilled to have such a great place so nearby. They also give nostalgic candy with the bill. I have never had a bad meal here, and I've probably been there a dozen times since I discovered it in Msy...

Thanks Straw!

Posted by Paul R on Aug. 12, 2011 @ 12:49 am


Thank you so much for coming in (on the regular!:) You're comments really mean a lot, and we're psyched to contribute to Hayes Valley.

See you around!

Posted by Greg on Aug. 12, 2011 @ 9:16 am

Also from this author

  • The last supper

    Food writer Paul Reidinger bids farewell after more than a decade covering the San Francisco food scene

  • Radish

    Staging well-crafted feats of new all-American, neatly tucked away from the Valencia Street h-words

  • Boxing Room

    A warm Hayes Valley spot that punches up the Cajun trend with lagniappe, mirilton, and po'boys