Disappearing poles

New supervisors Breed and Yee help create a less predictable board

London Breed (left) and Norman Yee celebrate on election night.


Political dynamics on the Board of Supervisors moved into uncertain new territory this week with the inauguration of two new members -– London Breed and Norman Yee –- who break the mold in representing districts that have long been predictable embodiments of opposite ideological poles.

Breed and Yee are both native San Franciscans with deep roots in their respective districts, which they tapped to win hotly contested races against challengers who seemed more closely aligned with the progressive politics of Dist. 5 and the fiscally conservative bent of Dist. 7. Both tell the Guardian that they represent a new approach to politics that is less about ideology and more about compromise and representing the varied concerns of their diverse constituencies.

"I don't see everything as a compromise, but I want to be sure we find compromises where we can and don't let personalities get in the way," said Yee, whose background working in education and facilitating deals as a school board member belies District 7's history of being represented by firebrand opponents of the progressive movement.

Some of the strongest champions of the pro-tenant, anti-corporate progressive agenda have come from the Haight and Dist. 5, a role that Breed has no intention of playing. "When you talk about the progressives of San Francisco, I don't know that I fit in that category," Breed told us. "I'm a consensus builder. I want to get along with people to get what I want."

Yet what Breed says she wants are housing policies that protect renters and prevent the exodus of African-Americans, and development standards that preserve the traditional character of neighborhoods against corporate homogenization. "I don't see the difference between my causes and progressive causes," she said, claiming a strong independence from some of the monied interests that supported her campaign.

We spoke a few days before the Jan. 8 vote for board president (which was scheduled after Guardian press time, and which you can read about at the SFBG.com Politics blog). Neither Yee nor Breed would tip their hands about who they planned to support -– the first potential indication of their willingness to buck their districts' ideological leanings.

Breed had raised some progressive eyebrows by telling the Guardian and others that she admired moderate Sup. Scott Wiener and would support him for president, but she had backtracked on that by the time we spoke on Jan. 5, telling us, "I'm going into this with an open mind.

"I'm waiting on my colleagues to decide who has the most votes," Breed said, ing a candid take on valuing compromise over conflict. "I really would like to see us walk into this all together."

Yee had similar comments. "They're all competent people and can be leaders, it just depends on where they want to lead us," he said. "I value people who can work with anyone and see themselves as facilitators more than as dictators."

Both Breed and Yee come from humble roots that they say give them a good understanding of the needs of the city's have-nots. Breed was raised in the public housing projects of the Western Addition, an experience that makes her want to solve the current dysfunction in the San Francisco Housing Authority.

"I can't tell you what needs to be done, but I can tell you something is wrong," Breed told us. "My goal is to get to the bottom of it and be extremely aggressive about it."

Yee grew up in Chinatown, his father an immigrant who worked as a janitor, his mother a garment worker. They later lived in the Sunset and the Richmond, and Yee moved into his district's Westwood Park neighborhood 26 years ago.

When Yee was eight years old, the family saved enough money to open a grocery store at 15th and Noe, and he said that he basically ran the store in his teen years while his father continued working another job.


The idea of Supervisors who are not ideologically bound but rather favor consensus and co-operation is great for anyone except those who seek to confer a dictatorship on the city.

The people and voters should decide policy, not activists machinating behind closed doors.

Posted by Anon on Jan. 10, 2013 @ 4:35 pm

He knows that - he's not going to alienate the people of his district who are for the large part upper middle class homeowners. While his roots may be in Chinatown that brand of politics doesn't play well in West Portal - which is why he decided to support Chiu despite Rose Pak's demands he do differently.

Posted by Lucretia Snapples on Jan. 10, 2013 @ 4:51 pm

those who seek office are lawyers, activists, government workers or professional politicians. Whenever I see someone standing for office who has actually run a small business, I vote for them because they understand basic economics and the crucial role of business in conferring prosperity.

While Breed, alto not fitting that category, is way more credible than Ross and Olague, in the same way that Kim is way better than Daly and the appalling Debra Walker.

We're good here.

Posted by Guest on Jan. 10, 2013 @ 5:01 pm

But it sure is going to hurt District 5. LMAO. She claims (Breed) not to know "what needs to be done" but she knows something is wrong. What a joke. And she's right about NOT being progressive because her staff and sub-staff over @ AAACC looks like Obama's cabinet, not like the diverse, Western Addition projects that Ms. Breed came from...allegedly. You'd expect someone tooting what great works they plan to do for the "African-Americans" of District 5, would have at least a few folks on staff that look like the Fillmore/Western Addition. It is after all 20-13. But not for Ms. Breed. And her being on the budget committee is a joke as well. She has mismanaged AAACC's budget for years. Smh. She's been in the district for at least the last 15 years....AND DOESN'T KNOW WHAT HAS TO BE DONE. Lord this is going to be fun too watch, and too see if the new sheep of D5 give her a pass.

Posted by GuestTitus Moreland on Jan. 20, 2013 @ 11:51 am

How about those million dollar homeowners in cole Valley and Buena Vista? Don't they count? They sure should, since they helped defeat all the progressives in D5 this past November.

Posted by Guest on Jan. 20, 2013 @ 1:51 pm