The cost of fake cabs

Start-ups could put the city $300 million in the hole

Mayor Ed Lee just loves the new ride-shares.

Hansu Kim has been involved in the San Francisco taxi industry for more than a decade. He helped design the current system of buying and selling cab permits, or medallions. In 2011, he led a group that bought DeSoto Cab, and now he runs what many say is the best-managed livery company in the city. Taxis are his career — and he's about ready to pull the plug.

"You can quote me on this, because I'm very serious," Kim told us. "If the city can't solve this problem, DeSoto will drop out of the taxi business. We'll run limos or something else. Because the whole industry is headed for collapse."

The problem Kim is talking about: The rise of companies that act like cabs, offering rides for hire, but operate outside of the rules and regulations that the traditional industry is mandated to follow.

They're called Lyft, Sidecar, Uber, and Tickengo, and they offer the same basic model: You can track a ride on your phone based on geolocation, the driver can choose whether to pick you up — and you pay a fee that the companies call voluntary but everyone knows is the basis of a venture-capital-funded business model.

They refuse to accept the city's oversight, running without the medallions that traditional cabs need to pick up passengers.

Cab regulators are furious: "Those of us who know the situation know there's a reason that taxis have been regulated for 350 years," Chris Hayashi, who runs the taxis division of the city's Municipal Transportation Agency, told us. "If you follow this to its logical conclusion, it will kill the entire industry."

That's a problem for a number of reasons — for one thing, Hayashi said, "you're not going to find one of these new services picking up a disabled grandmother at the hospital and taking her home to the housing projects."

But there's another element that policy-makers need to consider: By allowing the faux cabs to operate, the city is risking the loss of some $300 million in projected revenue, money that is supposed to underwrite Muni and public transit.

Hundreds of drivers who bought medallions with long-term loans may wind up underwater — and the local credit union that financed them could lose millions.


Two years ago, San Francisco radically changed the way it distributes taxi medallions. Since 1978, the valuable permits were given out essentially free to working drivers, on the basis of a waiting list that could be as long as 15 years.

Now, they're sold at a fixed rate; any active driver can buy one, and every time one is bought or sold, the city gets a substantial cut.

There's a lot of money involved. The permits have been selling for $300,000, and the city has roughly 1,000 available, and is considering issuing 800 more. Over the next 10 to 15 years, Hayashi agrees, the city's take could approach $300 million.

Some 300 have already been sold, with most of the drivers taking out a special loan from San Francisco Federal Credit Union. It's a good deal — a permit holder can count on not only the money from driving but another $2,500 or so a month from renting the medallion out for shifts when he or she isn't in the car.

But competition from Lyft and the others has already eroded the value of the medallions. "Absolutely, it's happening," Hayashi said. "We're asking the commission to lower the price to $250,000 to reflect that."

And they may have to lower it more — a lot more — in the future.

Everybody agrees the city's taxi industry is a mess — customers constantly complain that they can't find cabs, particularly at busy times. And the new tech-driven alternatives have sprung up to provide competition.

Related articles

  • More unregulated cabs on the street

  • The unregulated cabs

    Community taxi apps seem like a good idea -- but they're going to put people out of work 

  • The failure of Lee's business tax plan

  • Also from this author


    Anyone but Ed Lee. Peskin for Supervisor. Yes on F and I. Complete endorsements for the Nov. 3 election

  • David Chiu's flextime

  • The Mission 'douchebags'