Buddha with a Mohawk
Noah Levine fuses Eastern
religion and Western rebellion.
By A.C. Thompson
IT'S ABOUT 9:30 on a chilly April morning, and the three-week
Iraq war is still in full body-dropping swing, with Sherman tanks trundling
across the desert and missiles screaming into Baghdad apartment complexes.
Here in San Francisco, about 35 antiwarriors are congregating outside
the barricaded doors of the imposing federal office tower at 450 Golden
Gate Ave. The protesters, mostly white, many of them white-haired, are
religious types driven by their respective scriptural traditions to
oppose armed conflict and, on this day, to clasp hands and sing a quavering
rendition of "Amazing Grace."
It's an austere-looking, über-earnest crowd. Quakers. Members
of a group called the Buddhist Peace Fellowship. Catholics Friar
Louis Vitale, the bespectacled, robe-clad Franciscan pastor of the Tenderloin's
St. Boniface parish, and Father Bill O'Donnell, a Catholic Worker from
Berkeley.
Then there's Noah Levine.
He's the young guy puffing on a cigarette, slurping coffee, and cracking
jokes. Tattoos crawl down to his fingernails. A black beanie covers
his cue-ball head. Dark sunglasses hide his face. Guy looks more like
a meth-peddling biker escaped from the state pen than like a religious
devotee.
The protesters pass the bullhorn to Levine. He pauses dramatically
... then commences speaking in a calm, practiced voice. "I choose,
inspired by Buddhist practice and understanding, not to see war, not
to see hatred, but to look out and see ignorance," Levine says.
"Caring, compassion, and generosity are the only things that work....
We should be as Mahatma Gandhi said, 'the peace that we wish to
see in this world.' "
At 32, Levine is rapidly becoming one of the Bay Area's most sought-after
purveyors of Buddhist wisdom, his schedule crammed with speaking gigs
and lectures; his memoir, Dharma Punx, a plainspoken tale of
spiritual odyssey, was just released by a major publishing house: HarperCollins.
Practicing Buddhism isn't exactly radical in California, where Hollywooders
like Richard Gere photo-op with Tibetan monks, yoga is practically the
state pastime the San Francisco yellow pages alone lists more
than 60 yoga studios and the Dalai Lama literally plays to sold-out
stadia, as His Holiness did a few years back at Mountain View's Shoreline
Amphitheatre. But Levine happens to be a card-carrying member of the
punk subculture a scene that generally views all things religious
with contempt which makes him something of an iconoclast both
in punk circles and in the Buddhist community. There ain't a lot of
punkers with "Wisdom" and "Compassion" inked on
their hands. And how many Buddhists have been known to slam dance? Levine,
it seems, is a walking paradox, the strange embodiment of two thoroughly
incompatible worldviews.
Or maybe he isn't.
"I love being a punk rock Buddhist. I love the contradictions,"
Levine tells me. "The Buddha said, 'Go forth and speak the dharma
[the lessons of the Buddha] in your own idiom.' I know what the Buddha
taught, and I phrase it in my own generational perspective."
This intriguing punk-preacher duality has a way of propelling Levine
into wildly disparate social settings. One morning the Richmond District
resident is hanging with a bunch of people who could be his parents
or grandparents pontificating about the virtues of behaving
gently. That afternoon he'll be locked in a room at San Quentin State
Prison teaching meditation techniques to a half dozen stone-faced cons.
By night, he'll likely be ripping around town in his pristine 1964 Impala,
Rancid cranked to 11 on the stereo, on his way to see some bile-laden
three-chord punk band in some dive bar.
All of this begs the question, How the hell did a scumbag punk rocker
from Santa Cruz come to be regarded as a serious guide to the metaphysical
realm?
• • •
Zen fascists will control you.
Dead Kennedys
Not to do any evil, to cultivate good, to purify one's mind, this
is the Teaching of the Buddhas.
The Buddha
Linus had a security blanket. Noah Levine had a metal-handle steak
knife. Then five years old, he secreted it in the dirt beneath the wooden
steps to his house, a two-bedroom redwood-paneled home in the Santa
Cruz mountains ruled by what he describes as a drug-challenged mother
and an "evil stepfather."
When Levine got anxious or desperate or enraged, he dug out the blade
and contemplated its nonculinary applications. He developed two plans:
he could skewer himself, punching the knife into his heart, or he could
sneak up on his stepfather as he slept and kill him.
The stepfather eventually bailed, escaping with his life. Levine's
childhood, though, didn't get any smoother. By the age of 10, he was
destroying himself incrementally, getting bent on a regular basis with
a friend. "It's kind of tough when you're 10 years old to score
drugs, so we resorted to stealing what we could from our relatives and
got into stuff like sniffing paint and engine cleaner," he writes
in Dharma Punx. "Anything that would make us dizzy would
do."
In 1980, at the age of 10, Levine heard a tape of the Sex Pistols.
He was sold immediately. It was the Reagan era, when it seemed the cold
war would climax at any minute with an apocalyptic exchange of
nukes, and Johnny Rotten's "no future" posturing and
the band's amusical buzz-saw sonics spoke to the prepubescent shit-disturber.
Levine says his attraction to punk was partially fueled by an awareness
of "the glaring injustice in the world" and the "hopelessness"
of the time. "But more honestly, I was more pissed at my own family
situation a broken home, a dysfunctional and addicted mom, an
abusive stepdad."
As a teenager Levine spent his days skateboarding and his nights circle-pitting.
He was the guy at the gigs bands like Corrosion of Conformity,
Millions of Dead Cops, and 7 Seconds blitzed on Schaeffer's or
jelloed on a couple tabs of acid, wearing a Magic Markered Postal Service
shirt, his hair dyed fire-engine red and chopped into a Mohawk.
In 10th grade he got into slumming with a pack of homeless gutter punks
(including a girl gang called the Hell Bitches, who reveled in leaving
bloody fingernail marks on the boys they humped, and a heroin-loving
guy who proudly sported a tattoo of a syringe), getting wasted and smoking
crack.
"I was in pain, and I was angry, and drugs worked to numb that
pain," Levine says. "In some ways, drugs propelled the anger,
and I acted out violently under the influence. But in another way, drugs
were a solution in the beginning. I found that I could drink, or smoke,
or shoot dope, and it took the edge off the pain I was feeling."
The guards at the Santa Cruz County Juvenile Hall were well acquainted
with Levine, who had a penchant for running afoul of the law and once
had to be hog-tied while in custody. Over the span of a few years he
was popped for weed possession (five times), strong-arm robbery (he
nabbed an elderly lady's purse), attacking a jock with a skateboard
(he bashed the guy in the cranium), and stealing a car stereo (he was
too wasted to run away from the cops).
As a teenage rebel, Levine dutifully rejected the advice of his pop,
Stephen Levine, a best-selling Buddhist author who was remarried and
dwelling in the granola-ish town of Taos, N.M. The younger Levine despised
hippies his father was a product of the '60s who palled around
with New Age icons Ram Dass and Jack Kornfield. Levine didn't want to
have anything to do with anything remotely spiritual.
Lockdown changed that. After what he calls a "half-assed"
suicide attempt that landed him in a padded cell (he'd tried to slit
his wrists with a plastic comb before smashing his head on the jailhouse
wall), Levine got a call from his dad. Stephen Levine, Noah writes in
his autobiography, "suggested that some simple meditation techniques
might alleviate the pain I was feeling. He explained to me that by 'bringing
the mind into the present moment, the present experience of being, I
may be able to find some freedom in that moment from the regret of the
past and the fear of the future.' "
Today this practice of letting go lies at the heart of Noah Levine's
lessons. "The basis of what I'm trying to teach is present-time
awareness, mindfulness of the present."
• • •
I want his beautiful religion to burn.
Born Against
Happy indeed we live without hate among the hateful.
The Buddha
Like Noah Levine, Siddhartha Gautama wasn't the cheeriest young man.
Born to an affluent and powerful family in the Indian foothills of the
Himalayas in the sixth century B.C.E., Guatama was haunted by dark thoughts.
"When he looked at human life," religious historian Karen
Armstrong writes in her bio, Buddha, Guatama "could see
only a grim cycle of suffering, which began with the trauma of birth
and proceeded inexorably to 'aging, illness, death, sorrow and corruption.'
He himself was no exception to this universal rule. At present he was
young, healthy and handsome, but whenever he reflected on the suffering
that lay ahead, all the joy and confidence of youth drained out of him.
His luxurious lifestyle seemed meaningless and trivial."
At the age of 29, he left his wife and child to wander the countryside
in search of a spiritual antidote to human misery. This wasn't a particularly
revolutionary act there were swarms of bhikkhus, ascetic
Hindu beggar-monks, roaming around India at the time. Guatama, according
to Armstrong, "believed that he was setting out on an exciting
adventure."
Six years later, after logging countless miles on the road, torturing
himself through starvation and dehydration, engaging in extended silent
yoga sessions, and doing a whole lot of introspection, Guatama, according
to legend, achieved nirvana liberation from the realm of suffering
while meditating under a tree. Adopting the title Buddha (enlightened
one), he proceeded to verbally lay out the route to nirvana, the Noble
Eightfold Path essentially "The Buddha's Guide to Better
Living." It includes prohibitions on telling lies and gossiping,
a ban on violence, and according to late scholar Walpola Rahula, an
instruction to train the mind to abandon "all sensations, even
of happiness and unhappiness, of joy and sorrow," letting only
"pure equanimity and awareness" remain.
In one semi-enigmatic verse titled "Crossing the Stream,"
Buddha describes the process of attaining enlightenment like this:
Few cross over the river.
Most are stranded on this side.
On the riverbank they run up and down.
But the wise person, following the way,
Crosses over, beyond the reach of death.
Free from desire,
Free from possessions,
Free from attachment and appetite,
Following the seven lights of awakening,
And rejoicing greatly in one's freedom,
In this world the wise person
Becomes oneself a light,
Pure, shining, free.
(translated by Jack Kornfield)
• • •
I'm a person just like you
But I've got better things to do
Then sit around and smoke dope
'Cause I know that I can cope.
Minor Threat
Whoever is energetic, mindful, pure in conduct, discriminating,
self-restrained, right-living, vigilant, his fame steadily increases.
The Buddha
Levine's tentative steps toward the spiritual life didn't translate
into instant sainthood. After getting cut loose from an East Palo Alto
group home ("a storage facility to keep kids like me off the streets")
at 18, he knocked around Santa Cruz, toiling at a pizza place, scamming
on girls, brawling, and breaking enough traffic laws to lose his driver's
license and get his vintage Triumph motorcycle impounded. He also made
the front page of the Santa Cruz Sentinel when he got arrested
on a slew of felony vandalism charges for graffiti and was facing more
time in the clink, with prosecutors asking for a two-year prison
sentence.
Simultaneously, however, Levine was showing some signs of getting his
shit together. He'd discovered the straight-edge scene (drug- and alcohol-free
punkers inspired by hardcore band Minor Threat) and became a regular
at 12-step recovery meetings.
Depressed and waiting to be sentenced on the graffiti charges, he began
exploring Eastern religious movements a decision partially prompted
by his experiences with 12-stepping, which pushes the concept of surrendering
to a "higher power." (The judge spared Levine prison time
but hit him with $10,000 in restitution and 500 hours of community service.)
Like everything in his life, Levine's spiritual road trip was a study
in extremes. For a while he fell under the spell of a guru who claimed
to be an otherworldly incarnation of "pure love" and was eventually
busted for child molestation. At 20 he took a two-year vow of celibacy.
"That period of celibacy gave me the incredible experience of being
with desire and not satisfying it," he told Tricycle magazine
in 2000. "I was choosing for the cultivation of my own spiritual
practice that I wasn't going to be sexual no masturbation, no
intercourse, complete restraint."
Still, Levine was definitely holding on to his punk surliness. When
he went on a retreat with Thich Nhat Hanh, the famed Vietnamese Buddhist,
he found himself dissing the crowd. "My mind tended toward judging
and resenting all of the rich, white Buddhists who were there with their
brand new BMWs and designer clothes," he writes in Dharma Punx.
Later, embarking on a five-month pilgrimage to Asia, Levine planned
to wrap himself in the robes of Buddhist monkdom. At one temple in Burma
he was baffled to find the monks training cats to jump through hoops
rather than meditating or studying scripture. At another, a monk who
had a long-running grudge against Levine's dad gave him grief. After
several aborted attempts at ordaining, he found he couldn't commit and
returned to the states.
In the opinion of Vinny Ferraro, a close friend who accompanied him
to Asia, "he was taking himself too fucking seriously. He was all
suped-up on ordaining."
When the monk thing didn't work out, Levine moved to San Francisco
and hooked up with people at the opposite end of the spectrum: convicts.
He started working for the Mind Body Awareness Project, a small nonprofit
that offers free nonreligious meditation classes for state
prison inmates and juvenile offenders at Alameda County Juvenile Hall.
It was a natural move for Levine: if he hadn't gotten clean, he probably
would've wound up living in a cage, a fate that had befallen a good
number of his comrades. Levine, who is currently pursuing a master's
in psychological counseling at the California Institute of Integral
Studies, a small San Francisco school focused on Eastern philosophy,
also leads a therapy group for prisoners grappling with drug addiction
and does one-on-one psychotherapy sessions.
Ferraro, who volunteers with Levine at San Quentin, says close contact
with cons keeps Levine from slipping into a "soft-core, Marin County"
state of mind. ("All that workshop language is too cosmic,"
he gripes.) In prison, Ferraro notes, "either the guy is gonna
dig you, or he's gonna bust you in the mouth."
San Quentin inmate Jarvis Jay Masters explains the value of meditation
from a prisoner's perspective. "Having a meditation practice helps
me tremendously," says Masters, a convicted murderer who converted
to Buddhism. When meditating, he says, "I don't feel like I am
on death row or in the hellhole of the Adjustment Center [the solitary
confinement unit], but in a very real way I'm connected to others."
Ron Johnson, the assistant director of Alameda County's juvenile lockup
has praise for the Mind Body Awareness Project, which works with serious
offenders, including teens accused of homicide. "It's an excellent
program. Teaching children to control their emotions through meditation
helps them to adjust to life in our facility," Johnson tells me,
adding that it seems to cut down on the general aggression level.
• • •
Let us stand and activate for the living, to rescue those about
to die at the hands of bullshit politicians.
Propagandhi
The wise let go of the "self" and being free of attachments
they depend not on knowledge.
The Buddha
Religion and punk "are a strange fit," argues Dan Sinker,
the editor of Punk Planet, a Chicago-based bimonthly magazine.
"Organized religion, no matter how groovy, is a weird thing to
shoehorn into or around punk."
In a certain regard, punk and Buddhism are underpinned by a similar
premise: both acknowledge that the planet is brimming with unhappiness.
The question is how you confront that misery.
Punkers, by definition, buck the status quo. That could mean running
amok, as Levine and company did. But for a lot of punks, it means trying
to uproot the establishment by becoming a hacker or a zinester or a
pirate radio DJ or a hardcore activist like the hordes of punkers
who paralyzed the S.F. streets during the antiwar uprising, and the
streets of Seattle during the anti-World Trade Organization protests.
It's easy to read the Buddha's prescription as a surefire way to keep
people from challenging real-world inequity and evil; India during his
day was rived by a gaping chasm between rich and poor, a situation worsened
by the immutable caste system. So what did the wise one say? Yeah, the
world is fucked up. It's always going to be that way.
Still, there's another take on Buddhism, one that's gaining increasing
acceptance, especially among Western Buddhists. In the eyes of "engaged"
Buddhists, the enlightened one wasn't an apologist for business as usual,
but a veritable insurrectionist who'd exhort the faithful to actively
respond to injustice if he were around today.
This incarnation of Buddhism appeals to some of Levine's students.
"Why are the Dharma Punx attracted to this way of life?" asks
one pupil, a woman named Bodhi. "For me, what the Buddha was teaching
was really revolutionary. It's commonly referred to as 'against the
stream'; it invites people to go a different way, to cultivate wisdom
and compassion. Since I was a girl, I've been disturbed by the stupor
I see around me. Most people are checked out, going along with traditions
the traditions of family, of their country, of whatever."
Levine himself seems torn on the issue of societal engagement. On one
hand you'll find him at the No War demo, on the other he says he has
no interest in affecting widespread social change. "My perspective
is that the system is totally fucked. Always has been and probably always
will be. And I don't think I can change it.... I believe totally and
completely in personal transformation. I don't have a lot of hope for
systems to change."
Buddhism, he says, is a somewhat "exclusionary thing. I don't
think everybody can get it. Only the wise are gonna get it, but I think
punks are wise."
• • •
We don't follow any rules or laws.
The Casualties
Hatred is never appeased by hatred in this world. This is an eternal
Law.
The Buddha
The "Urban Dharma" group taught by Levine meets every Wednesday
in a well-maintained brick building on the corner of Fulton Street and
Third Avenue, just across from Golden Gate Park. It's an April night,
and Levine sits cross-legged before a group of perhaps 40 people, most
of them outsider types: burly dudes with neck tattoos, women with tricolored
hair and spiky clothes. Next to Levine sits a white plastic statue of
a skinny Buddha adorned with a Mohawk.
Topic A is annica, the elementary concept that everything in
life is transitory and fleeting. "Nothing is solid. Nothing is
unchanging. Nothing externally, nothing internally," Levine says.
"You can't hold on to pleasure, and you can't get away from pain."
Personal suffering is generated by "trying to hold on to something
you can't hold on to."
Levine's lecture moves on to the Noble Eightfold Path. The Buddha,
he tells the group, counseled "avoiding that which is unwholesome"
by restraining ourselves "from activities that are unwholesome,
activities such as violence, such as greed, such as hatred." The
prohibition on bad behavior extends to the mental realm just
thinking about kicking someone's ass is verboten. "It's pretty
hard to avoid unwholesome feelings and thoughts, maybe even impossible,
I think. I haven't been able to get there, that's for sure," Levine
relates, giggling; the room erupts in laughter.
This sort of casual explication of the dharma has had a gargantuan
impact on people like Mike Haber. Haber, who skateboards to our interview
in a ripped denim vest and a black Hunns T-shirt, was virulently antireligious
as a younger punk. The oxish character was also the wrong guy to fuck
with and once bit off part of a dude's ear during a fight. These days
you can find a remarkably tranquil Haber meditating daily and volunteering
at the Zen Hospice Project, a San Francisco nonprofit that cares for
the terminally ill. Last week Haber spent 48 hours at the bedside of
a man in the final throes of brain cancer. He intends to move to Thailand
to become a monk.
"Noah's been a really good teacher for me because he's not perfect
and he doesn't claim to be," Haber tells me.
Eric Rodriguez geysered the first time he meditated with Levine. It
was a session aimed at generating feelings of forgiveness. Rodriguez
says, "I started thinking about my dad and just broke down crying.
I hadn't cried for years."
• • •
I will not bow down.
Hatebreed
The fault of others is easily seen; but one's own is hard to see.
The Buddha
One of Levine's friends says Levine is "so charismatic and real
that people look into his eyes and fall in love with him."
Riding shotgun in Levine's thunderous deep red Impala, I ask if he's
worried about becoming a guru, about getting weird and creepy and somehow
exploiting the people who show up to hear him talk dharma. He says no.
I ask him about his material life the full-sleeve tattoos, the
slick car, the gold teeth. Aren't serious Buddhists supposed to live
simply and renounce worldly possessions? "I don't care about any
of this stuff," he says. "It's not important to me."
Later we come back to the guru subject. With his autobiography hitting
store shelves and a major book tour about to jump off, Levine is poised
to become a media darling. Salon.com has already run a lengthy feature,
and NPR called today. "When I get attention, I have this ego that
really likes it," he admits, quickly pointing out that "it's
not about Noah. It's about the dharma.
"I'm working on maintaining humility in this life of mine that
seems to be going more and more public."
E-mail A.C. Thompson at ac_thompson@sfbg.com.