A powerful attraction
Moscone's Julius Caesar at Cal Shakes avoids the too familiar good-evil paradigm to examine self-interest and ambition.

By Robert Avila

WHEN ORSON WELLES and his Mercury Theater Company produced Julius Caesar in 1937, it fit perfectly into the popular front-era landscape of socially conscious theater. Welles simply set the play in fascist Italy. But in the end, Shakespeare doesn't do agitprop, even in so politically charged a play as this. Just the opposite: in his endlessly subtle meditation on power, he accommodates everyone from anarchists to autocrats.

This is as true today, when California Shakespeare Theater and artistic director Jonathan Moscone make the object of the play our own time as much as Caesar's. In Cal Shakes's first season offering, a paralleling of ancient Rome and the world's latest empire permeates the production design. The centerpiece of John Coyne's set, which has a kind of Las Vegas majesty about it, is an enormous billboard dominated by a bust of Caesar (L. Peter Callender), while Katherine Roth's fetching costumes offer a sci-fi blend of toga and 21st-century business chic, more Romulan than Roman.

The actors, too, strike decidedly American poses. As the play opens, Caesar and the Roman masses are basking in the former's recent military triumph, while a group of conspirators ultimately led by Marcus Brutus (Charles Shaw Robinson) plots to murder the man whose unprecedented power threatens to destroy the republic. Coconspirator Cassius (the excellent James Carpenter) wears large metal-rimmed glasses that, with his businessman's hair, give him the look of a deeply disgruntled ACLU attorney (albeit one supported by camouflaged cadres brandishing M-16s and night-vision scopes). The equally appealing Robinson as a quiet, philosophical Brutus could pass as a Democrat from Wisconsin. Callender's charismatic Caesar, meanwhile, an adept and sympathetic mixture of megalomania and insecurity, is a media-savvy political genius who gives off, while in domestic repose, an almost Brat Pack cool (which puts him right at home in Las Vegas). And his loyal Marc Antony (a robust Andy Murray) is a sort of all-American in coliseum garb, with the power of the demagogue to convert the public into a murderous mob.

If Elizabethans were inclined to relate to the imperial aspects of the story, and to lionize Caesar, Americans have traditionally seen the play as an allegory of republican virtue over tyranny, with Brutus its hero. This tendency goes back to the country's founders, who self-consciously emulated the model they found in the ancient republican. But Brutus is also deeply flawed, wedded to abstractions that move his loyalties from people to ideas and leave him out of touch with reality. At least as understandable is Cassius's opposition to Caesar, which, though often dismissed as mere envy, stems from the trampled dignity of a freeborn individual. In Cassius's wooing of Brutus to the side of the conspirators, his republican sentiments sound a typically American note of self-reliance: "Men at some time are masters of their fate / The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, / But in ourselves, that we are underlings."

But do Americans still side automatically with Brutus and Cassius? Lip service to democratic values can't hide the current fascination with empire present not only in Washington, D.C., but also increasingly in the culture at large. Far from looking to Jesus Christ for guidance, those in power today (and those swayed by them) seem much more interested in what Julius Caesar had to say, at least metaphorically speaking. And if there's a moral dimension at all to their embrace of J.C. (à la prattle about a Pax Americana pacifying and civilizing an unruly planet), it usually smacks of self-serving afterthoughts in calculations of power for power's sake.

So who is the play's real hero? If director Moscone knows, he's not telling, which fits the moment and the play to a T. While the tension and clarity of an impressive first act dissipate somewhat in a more desultory second half, the ambivilence we feel in the end has less to do with the production's minor weaknesses. And if you find that bothersome, then you must have been born in the USA – land of good and evil, heroes and villains, and easy answers to complicated problems. In Julius Caesar, history and art produce a cast of chameleon figures for all time, sophisticated political archetypes illuminated by the playwright's own power to convey the twisted skein of human nature.

'Julius Caesar'
runs through June 22. Tues.-Thurs., 7:30 p.m.; Fri.-Sat., 8 p.m. (also Sat., 2 p.m.); Sun., 4 p.m., Bruns Memorial Amphitheater, Highway 24 at Shakespeare Festival Way/Gateway Boulevard exit, Orinda. $13-$49. (510) 548-9666, www.calshakes.org.


June 11, 2003