Finding Niki
A critic goes deep into
the belly of Whale Rider.
By B. Ruby Rich
NIKI CARO CARRIES in her wallet a photo of a young woman standing
atop a giant, unmoving whale on an isolated beach at dawn. It's not
a bad metaphor for embarking on the unknown, with equal parts temerity
and trepidation. It's not a bad metaphor for filmmaking, either, considering
that the young woman is Caro herself on the day she accepted Whale
Rider as a film project and immediately heard of a whale dead on
the sand near her beach house. "We've been haunted by whale strandings
throughout this film process," she explains. "On the day we
announced the film, two whales came into the bay [at Auckland], circled
twice, and left. All the Maori people immediately said, 'Oh, you're
blessed.' " Sitting in her Auckland kitchen, I study the photograph
and I'm impressed.
After she consulted Maori friends, sure the whale stranding was a bad
omen, Caro learned that traditionally "it was great luck to have
a whale stranded like that it meant that people got meat, oil,
bone for weapons." Lucky, that, because the whales have kept on
coming. Coinciding with the film's release in New Zealand, a mess of
whales were stranded on its remote Stewart Island. When I saw Caro and
her producer Linda Goldstein Knowlton in San Francisco on the day of
her San Francisco International Film Festival screening this past spring,
she mentioned a story on a big whale stranding in the Florida Keys (where
a whale also was stranded at the time of her Sundance
showing.) Some have escaped; some have died. By now, Caro is spooked:
"Ask them to stop now, please. I know it's a good sign, but ask
them to stop."
The film languished in development hell for more than a decade before
landing in her lap for its final rewrite, Caro tells me as she chops
vegetables and I admire the converted stable, where she lives with her
architect husband and their soon-to-be-born child, who is due
any day now. She hopes the film stays in theaters until the baby's arrival.
It's already been screening for 19 weeks, second only to Once Were
Warriors in New Zealand film history. In Australia, Whale Rider
has surpassed it, becoming the highest-grossing New Zealand film
ever shown. It's hard to believe, now, that for so many years, fits
and starts plagued the film adaptation of celebrated Maori writer Witi
Ihimaera's canonical novel (which was already mandatory reading in New
Zealand high schools before hitting the big screen). Basking in awards
from Maui to Rotterdam, Caro has an explanation for the long delay:
"I honestly think it had to wait until the world was ready for
it."
I'm not really supposed to be here I'm en route to a conference
and film festival jury in Australia but it's just too tempting
to play hooky and check up on the Whale Rider folks on the very
eve (or afternoon, by now, for you) of its launch in the United States.
How dear to my heart is Whale Rider, the little movie that could?
Working for the Toronto International Film Festival last year, I "discovered"
it in a drawer full of unsolicited work awaiting a turn on the VCR.
The experience of watching the not-yet-finished film take form on the
video monitor was truly one of those rare "aha" moments. As
international film programmer, I got to invite the movie and its makers,
introduce all of them at the world premiere, and watch, like
a proud parent, the standing ovations, a tribute from a tearful
Sam Neill, and the first audience award ever at Toronto for an "unknown"
film.
Caro doesn't seem surprised by all this in the least, nor does
she seem to derive the usual ego-fueled satisfaction that tends to inflate
filmmakers when they jump to the mainstream this way. (I call it the
"Sundance effect," when previously reasonable people suddenly
morph into unbearable divas after receiving a festival award or distribution
deal.) Being a New Zealander has given her an intriguing take on the
cosmos: she truly believes this film willed itself into being and has
somehow forged its own success.
In New Zealand, Maori culture is astonishingly integrated into the
life of the nation. "It's really one of the only indigenous cultures
in the world that has imposed its own culture on the colonizing culture,"
Caro tells me. She was acutely aware of her responsibility as a pakeha
(white person) to get Maori culture right when she took on the film.
She began to study the language "at least to get the pronunciation
right," she says to underscore her fledgling comprehension.
"I felt that it was a matter of respect."
I get a lesson in how material (as opposed to metaphoric) that integration
is when the writer himself, Ihimaera, comes to take us out for lunch.
Urban and urbane, he's a charming mischief-maker whose writings have
been crucial to New Zealand's understanding of itself. A product of
a Maori community, he grew up not far from Gilmore, where the film was
shot after tribal elders gave it their blessing.
Whale Rider, the novel, has a great origin story. Prior to his
current stint as a professor at the University of Auckland teaching
Maori and Pacific Island diasporic literature, Ihimaera was in the diplomatic
service. He was posted to the New York consulate office when a whale
happened to wander into the Hudson River, causing quite a fuss and reminding
him of home. Then his two daughters came to visit and he took them to
see an Indiana Jones movie, after which they complained how unfair it
was that movie heroes were always male. A myth was born.
In Auckland, Ihimaera is a dapper man-about-town. He picks us
up in a black-leather-lined BMW, and we tool down a gorgeous shoreline
road, Tamaki Drive, and stop at one particular vista for a walk. It's
called Bastion Point, but its Maori name is Takaparawha. In 1977 a group
of Maori calling themselves the Orakei Maori Action Committee occupied
this point to stop its planned development by the city and to demand
its return to the tribe. It was 506 days before the government sent
in troops to clear them out. But in an unprecedented court case, the
battle was won: today the Takaparawha Reserve is administered jointly
by the Auckland City Council and the Ngati Whatua o Orakei Trust Board
in a landmark settlement. After lunch Ihimaera gives me copies of two
of his other novels, and I'm further surprised: The Uncle's Story
and Nights in the Gardens of Spain are both wild coming-out
stories, full of bravado and sexual adventure.
By the time I leave New Zealand (which I now know is also called "Aotearoa,"
its Maori name), I've learned that its enlightened prime minister, Helen
Clarke, has given refugee status to Afghan youths and visits them at
their school twice a year. I've learned she kept New Zealand out of
the recent Iraq invasion, unlike its unfortunate neighbor Australia,
dragged in by a conservative government. I've learned that New Zealand
was the first country to grant women the vote in 1893, decades
ahead of the United States, Canada, and Europe. Significantly, its legislation
specifically included Maori women as having that right. Absorbing this
history, I begin to understand the tradition from which Whale Rider
draws: one of female leadership, courage, racial and cultural equity,
and political engagement. No wonder that Caro talks about her film as
a "model of leadership for these dark times." Boarding the
plane to Australia, I send up a wish that it inspires girls everywhere
to pursue power and use it wisely.
While in Sydney, I see the first posters for Finding Nemo and
have to laugh. A fish tank in a dentist's office overlooking Sydney
Harbor? I've had that view, thank you very much, without the dentist.
Every festival reception is in a room with a view. Even though it's
winter in Australia, the air sparkles with sunshine and warmth
"unseasonably," the Aussies all insist. By the time I return
to SFO, I've decided that the poster sighting was fortuitous. Finding
Nemo and Whale Rider, the perfect summer double bill: don't
see one without the other. Measure the distance between the two movies,
not just the miles and miles of ocean that take 13 hours to cross but
also the budgets that take so many zeros to equalize. And you will see
the difference between the powerful myths of that wonderful tiny land
Down Under, ringed by water and whales, and the animated fantasies concocted
with exquisite skill up here so that an audience, numb and under siege
in one of the worst epochs in our national history, can laugh and try
to hide all fear.
'Whale Rider' is currently playing at Bay Area theaters. See Movie
Clock, in Film listings, for show times.