Second Time Around

Spinners
The Chrome Collection (Rhino/Atlantic)

A Spinners greatest-hits compilation is as close to a sure thing as a fan of soul music can get – I have three from the past decade, and the music is so good that I can't part with any of them. The string of hits produced by Thom Bell during the '70s gives the group as strong a backbone as can be found in soul music; the power and consistency of their recordings are matched only by the work of Marvin Gaye, Al Green, and Stevie Wonder, among artists active during that decade – although as gifted, visionary songwriters, Gaye and Wonder had an element the Spinners lacked. Still, they lifted off with the Wonder-written 1970 smash "It's a Shame" and never looked back, recording rich, passionate, intricately crafted soul music that, though unmistakably stamped by singer Philippe Wynne, was so much more than a showcase for Wynne. In fact, Wynne joined after "Shame" and left before hits like "Workin' My Way Back to You/Forgive Me"); an argument could be made that Bell's genius in the recording studio was the key to their success, or that the on- and offstage harmony of the rest of the group – four of the original Spinners, which was formed in Detroit in 1961, are still in the group – was the essential if intangible ingredient. In any case, something was right – because, as The Chrome Collection proves, the Spinners made some incredible music over the years.

All of the hits are included on this three-CD set, along with songs like "Mighty Love," "Then Came You," "I'll Be Around," "Rubberband Man," and "Cupid/Love You For a Long Time," to name just a few. I'm generally indifferent to the booklets, etc. that come with so many compilations – and when I don't care, it's because I think they're fawning and irrelevant; but this box has one that's worth paying attention to, because as a group that was part of the Motown extended family in the '60s, and the Philly soul posse in the '70s, the Spinners' story is about much more than just a group. If I were marooned in, like, New York or some other awful place and got to take only 10 albums with me, this would be one of them. (J.H. Tompkins)


July 9, 2003