Techsploitation
By Annalee Newitz
Why
I infringe
I LIKE TO violate copyright everyday. Usually it's in some
small way. I'll copy an Oingo Boingo CD for a friend, xerox an interesting
essay from an anthology, or maybe download an episode of Six Feet
Under from a file-sharing network. Sometimes I go bigger, like when
I bought a bunch of cracked software from a guy who was literally standing
in a shady doorway, or when I bought a pirated DVD on the street in
New York City (yes, it looked like shit when I played it).
I only steal from the rich. Once I copied a Mountain Goats CD, because
I loved it so much and couldn't find it anywhere. As soon as I did,
I bought that CD and about five more by the same band. That was a situation
where I was sure the artist, who works through an independent label,
would actually get my money. I don't have that same feeling about creators
whose work is owned by giant media conglomerates. And frankly, I really
don't care if Danny Elfman never sees the money he might have made if
I hadn't copied that Oingo Boingo CD. He's rich enough as it is.
When I was a kid, I cried while reading Ray Bradbury's Fahrenheit
451, the dystopian novel about a future where books are illegal.
I can remember big, hot tears rolling down my face during the scene
in which the evil authorities are burning books. Bradbury describes
each one as if it were human: Alice from Alice in Wonderland
screams in agony; Shakespeare's characters weep as they are reduced
to ash.
I know it's sentimental of me, but I think of creative works as if
they were somehow human, as if they had lives of their own many
lives, playing out in strange, unknowable ways inside each mind that
absorbs them. And when I see art and music and writing and movies and
TV shows forbidden to me by draconian copyright laws, I don't think
about legal documents full of tidy little justifications of property
law. I see living beings in chains. I see Mickey Mouse, who has tried
to escape again, burned by the lash. I hear Marilyn Monroe, imprisoned
by her copyrighted image, howling to get free.
And I want to set her free. I want to see Marilyn running around in
the open air, somersaulting in the grass, smiling and pirouetting for
anyone who wants to watch her. I want people to invite her into their
own imaginations and turn her into something else.
I've never been one for pussyfooting around when it comes to liberating
what some corporation or mogul calls "private property." I
don't really give a shit about capitalism. I think it's a scam. Rich
guys who own everything trade stocks, and the rest of us, who own the
vast majority of nothing, watch welfare wither away. If we make something
beautiful and try to make a living by selling it, we can't own it. My
beautiful thing will be the property of some company that has slapped
a cover on it.
I'll leave it to Lawrence Lessig to explain how copyright limitations
can nourish free trade and moneymaking. I'll let Declan McCullagh explain
why there is no contradiction between capitalism and civil liberties
for all. I don't care if my file-sharing cripples the economy. I want
to rebel against the property holders, the people who took away our
beautiful things and called them commodities.
Until culture belongs to all of us equally, I will continue to infringe.
Annalee Newitz (gonif@techsploitation.com)
is a surly media nerd who once fell in love with someone because he
had cracked the copyright protection on her favorite piece of software.