The magic mountain
By Paul Reidinger
SWITZERLAND IS INDEED in part as mountainous
as myth makes it. Some years ago we flew into Zurich at dawn and were
entranced by the spectacle of a snowy city ringed by snowy peaks blushing
pink with the February sun's first rays. Yet the railway traveler, setting
out from, say, Lausanne en route to, say, Milan, knows that much of
that journey is a gentle descent along the south face of the
Alps, a country terraced and planted with wine grapes since time immemorial.
Yes, the Swiss make excellent wines, though they are tricky to find
in this country or, for that matter, anywhere outside Switzerland. The
Swiss export less than 1 percent of their annual wine production, and
most of that goes to Germany. An infinitesimal amount also ends up at
Matterhorn, a six-year-old restaurant (owned by Swiss-trained chef Andrew
Thorpe and his wife, Brigitte) so well concealed in a faceless building
somewhere between Russian Hill and Cow Hollow that you might easily
pass by it on your way to the ATM without noticing the modest sign announcing
its presence.
The low street profile does not seem to have put a dent in the restaurant's
business. Within walls paneled with some kind of blond wood (birch?
ash?) and under a gorgeous cove ceiling, Matterhorn seems to be reliably,
if quietly, abuzz at all times with parties great and small, with the
young and the old and the in-betweens, with locals and tourists, people
in sneakers and people in homburg hats. Are they all there for a sip
of Fendant, the crisp, fruity white wine from the Valais district? Or
perhaps of Dôle, a fine red (mostly pinot noir) from the same
region? Or have they shown up for fondue?
For fondue, in a variety of forms, is the heart of Matterhorn's menu
and doubtless a draw to groups in search of a certain sort of communal
dining experience. It is one thing to share small plates, as has become
the fashion in the last few years; it is quite another to take turns
cooking food over the restaurant equivalent of an open campfire. Fondue
must be one of the great bonding experiences people can have indoors,
though of course there are others that do not fall within the purview
of this sort of piece.
Fondue suggests, to most people, cheese fondue, and Matterhorn
offers it in a number of guises. The "original," or Valaisanne
version ($28 for two people), consists of a pool of Gruyère and
Emmentaler cheeses (along with a good shot of white wine and some undisclosed
herbs) bubbling in a chafing dish, and a basket of exquisitely soft,
house-baked bread cubes on the side. The cubes are fitted onto long
forks for dipping. In the interest of some extra heft, we added a side
of grilled, garlicky sausage slices ($4) dippable, but quite
satisfying on their own. And, as a further precaution to carbo overload,
we had opened with a plate of Walliser alpine delights ($7.50), a selection
of plump Black Forest ham, salami, prosciutto, and spicy cornichons,
preceded by simple green salads (part of the fondue) littered with tomato
quarters and chopped hard-boiled egg and dressed with a vinaigrette
enriched with egg yolk.
Recently I have heard it suggested that no matter how much good bread
you dip into vats of tasty melted cheese, you will come away feeling
somehow that you haven't properly had dinner. Matterhorn's answer to
these misgivings is one of the beef fondues, in which the bread is replaced
by sliced raw beef piled into a Matterhorn-like heap and the melted
cheese yields either to seasoned broth on the simmer or to hot oil.
Feeling slightly anxious about fat calories and having opened with a
fine, if caloric, raclette ($7.50) a plate of melted white cheese
ringed by new potatoes, cornichons, and pickled pearl onions
we thought the Chinoise broth ($40 for two) was the better part of valor.
And it did not disappoint.
Cooking beef in broth instead of oil means poaching it instead of frying
it. As poaching is less intense and more forgiving than frying, it is
easier to turn out slices of rosy, medium-rare (or even rare) meat.
Rare meat tends to be tender meat, and tender slices nearly melt into
one of the palette of sauces paprika, curry, horseradish, tartar,
whole-grain mustard, lingenberry, chutney offered on a separate
platter. And if the Matterhorn mountain of meat is overwhelming (which
does not mean two people can't polish it off anyway), one can always
turn to a wealth of side offerings: marinated mushrooms and artichoke
hearts, chunks of fresh kiwi and pineapple, spicy olives, and roasted
potato quarters in a crock. (These need no broth bath.)
Inevitably, there is fondue for dessert. That would be the chocolate
fondue ($14 for two), a pot of melted milk chocolate ready for dipping
with a host of fruits, including banana, cantaloupe, strawberries, apples,
grapes, and nectarines. Foolproof. But wanderers and malcontents might
enjoy an apfelstrudel ($7), plated amid broad daubs of a vanilla sauce
that powerfully resembled crème anglaise, or perhaps just a shot
of grappa ($6.95), variety being the proverbial spice of life. Switzerland,
with respect to variety, has a leg up on most of the rest of Europe,
if not the world; it has a finger in the estimable, but quite different,
culinary traditions of France, Germany, and Italy putting
it near if not at the top of the heap.
Matterhorn Restaurant. 2323 Van Ness (at Green), S.F. (415)
885-6116. Tues.-Sun., 5-8:30 p.m.; Fri.-Sat., 5-9:30 p.m. Full bar.
American Express, Diners Club, Discover, MasterCard, Visa. Not noisy.
Wheelchair accessible.