Second
Time Around
Eagles
The Very Best of the Eagles (WSM)
It's so uncool to even acknowledge the existence of the Eagles that I'm tempted to tell you about how I was ready to spill a little for Waylon Jennings by reviewing Lonesome, On'ry, and Mean. But the bright red on the cover of an Artist's Choice album caught my eye: Johnny Cash picking his favorite songs, including the fossilized "North to Alaska," by Johnny Horton (which is the theme song for a lousy John Wayne movie), and, more to the point, Linda Ronstadt's cover of the Eagles' "Desperado," along with a note from the Man in Black admitting he loved the tune so much he recorded it with Don Henley himself. I took this as a sign.
The '70s were tough all the way around. All the important things the '60s kids had to fight for dope, long hair, sex, no homework were played out. You had to ask yourself, Do I want to take drugs if my parents are taking drugs? And even if the answer was yes, the whole counterculture-becoming-mainstream thing kind of sucked. The Eagles, well, almost every rock fan loved the Eagles, secretly anyway, because even if they weren't ever much of a rock band, they made great pop music. And what else were you going to listen to? The Dolls and Bowie, 24-7? So you had to ask yourself again, Do I listen to "Lyin' Eyes," or do I listen to "Seasons in the Sun," "The Night Chicago Died," "Brandy," or "Alone Again (Naturally)"? No contest.
The fact is, the Eagles had five number-one singles and four number-one albums, and it didn't happen by accident. Henley and Glen Frey were a great songwriting team, and Henley's world-weary vocals on songs like "Best of My Love" and "One of These Nights" were pretty damn good. The real problem with the Eagles was they were too successful for too long the world couldn't forgive them. If Henley and Frey had O.D.ed or driven off a Laurel Canyon cliff the day before One of These Nights was released, history would have remembered the Eagles as tragedy rather than bloated comedy. Without the post-These Nights material, The Very Best of the Eagles would be one CD instead of two (which would be OK, because One of These Nights was their last great album), and you'd be listening to it on your way to meet your man. (J.H. Tompkins)