alt.sex.column

Archives|Andrea's Website| Biography| Ask Andrea

By Andrea Nemerson

Punch this

DEAR READERS: I was checking my Web site stats this morning, and I noticed that "donkey punch Cleveland steamer" was once again among the most popular search terms bringing new readers to my page. So, while I'm still puzzled and disconcerted by the public's apparently endless fascination with the topic, I give you the original "donkey punch" column and some of the follow-up discussion – and remind you not to blame me if you start to feel faint or morally outraged. I don't make this stuff up.

Love,
Andrea


Dear Andrea: A friend recently told me that during butt sex, if the guy punches the girl in the back of the head it will make her vomit and defecate at the same time. Is this true? And why would anyone want to do this?

Love,
Troubled

Dear Trouble: What? What?? Why would anyone want to do this, indeed? Come to think of it, why did your friend even tell you this thing to begin with? I mean, does this sort of thing come up in ordinary conversation? And one more question: does this friend have a girlfriend? It seems most unlikely, but I have no idea if it's true. I sincerely hope nobody gets it into his head to try it and tell me how it goes. In case anyone was leaning that way, I don't want to know, OK? Far, far more likely, I can see it going something like this: Guy punches girl in the back of the head during butt sex. Girl pulls away, turns and punches guy in the face, gets dressed, and leaves.

Love,
Andrea


Dear Andrea: Regarding "Troubled" 's recent question about punching a "girl" in the back of the head during "butt sex": One summer, over a spirited round of drinking games, a Harvard football player told us about this practice, which he named a "donkey punch." According to this Crimson Pervert, knocking the woman unconscious causes the sphincter to loosen, allowing deeper penetration. This was met, understandably, with uncomfortable silence and a general averting of eyes. No mention was made of defecation or vomiting, although they sound like not-unlikely side effects of cold-cocking an unsuspecting partner.

Neither he nor anyone present ever attempted a donkey punch, as far as I know. The same cannot be said for a "Cleveland steamer," another bit of sexual arcana he added to our collective lexicon that afternoon.

Yours,
Troubled by Harvard Student

Dear Troubled: Would it make you feel better about Harvard (if worse about mankind in general) to hear that the "donkey punch" is not, apparently, of Crimson Pervert origin? It appears that the phrase has been making the rounds, if my inbox is any indication. Anyway, ick. I don't know whether to be relieved or alarmed, but a quick search turns up evidence that Cleveland steamer, a practice if anything even more disgusting than the donkey punch, was likewise not invented by your churlish friend. It has its own T-shirt, for God's sake, available through the aptly named getoffended.com. And that is absolutely the last thing I intend to say about any of this.

Love,
Andrea


Dear Andrea: I am so angry that you did not mention in your discussion of the donkey punch that this type of activity is not some kind of "icky" fetish but falls into the category of assault and rape. I am disappointed that you never mentioned that once someone is unconscious, all sexual activity becomes nonconsensual. I would like you to issue an apology to your readers for your lack of appropriate responsibility as a journalist.

Love,
Another Woman Against Abuse of Women

Dear Woman: And I am so angry about those poor bonsai kittens! Imagine: being raised in a beer glass, never to eviscerate catnip mice or pounce on their owners' toesies early in the morning ... it's so mean! And isn't it too painful even to contemplate the fate of innocent companion rodents forced to perform despicable acts with aging Hollywood Buddhists? I don't know how you can get all exercised over violence to adult women, who, after all, can take care of themselves, while not sparing a tear for the poor little helpless furry ones. Honey, get over it. There's no such thing as a donkey punch. If there were, I promise you I'd be against it too. Until then, I don't believe I'll be apologizing, but thanks for the invitation.

Love,
Andrea


E-mail Andrea Nemerson at andrea@altsexcolumn.com.


May 12, 2004