It's hard not to like Treasurer/Tax Collector Jose Cisneros. He's charming, smart, compassionate, and has run this important office well for nine years, just the person that we need there to implement the complicated, voter-approved transition to a new form of business tax, a truly gargantuan undertaking.
Even our recent conflicts with Cisneros — stemming from frustrations that he won't assure the public that he's doing something about hotel tax scofflaw Airbnb (see "Into thin air," Aug. 6) — are dwarfed by our understanding of taxpayer privacy laws and admiration that Cisneros ruled against Airbnb and its ilk in the first place, defying political pressure to drop the rare tax interpretation.
So Cisneros has the Guardian's enthusiastic endorsement. He also has our sympathies for having to create a new system for taxing local businesses based on their gross receipts rather than their payroll costs, more than doubling the number of affected businesses, placing them into one of eight different categories, and applying complex formulas assessing how much of their revenues comes from in the city.
"This is going to be the biggest change to taxes in a generation," Cisneros told us of the system that he will start to implement next year, calling the new regime "a million times more complicated than the payroll tax."
Yet Cisneros has still found time to delve into the controversial realm of short-term apartment sublets. Although he's barred from saying precisely what he's doing to make Airbnb pay the $1.8 million in Transient Occupancy Taxes that we have shown the company is dodging, he told us, "We are here to enforce the law and collect the taxes."
And Cisneros has continued to expand his department's financial empowerment programs such as Bank on San Francisco, which help low-income city residents establish bank accounts and avoid being gouged by the high interest rates of check cashing outlets. That and similar programs are now spreading to other cities, and we're encouraged to see Cisneros enthusiastically exporting San Francisco values, which will be helped by his recent election as president of the League of California Cities.
SUPERVISOR, DIST. 4
With just six months on the job after being appointed by Mayor Ed Lee, Sup. Katy Tang faces only token opposition in this race. She's got a single opponent, accountant Ivan Seredni, who's lived in San Francisco for three years and decided to run for office because his wife told him to "stop complaining and do something," according to his ballot statement.
Tang worked in City Hall as a legislative aide to her predecessor, Carmen Chu, for six years. She told us she works well with Sups. Mark Farrell and Scott Wiener, who help make up the board's conservative flank. In a predominantly Chinese district, where voters tend to be more conservative, Tang is a consistently moderate vote who grew up in the district and speaks Mandarin.
Representing the Sunset District, Tang, who is not yet 30 years old, faces some new challenges. Illegal "in-law" units are sprouting up in basements and backyards throughout the area. This presents the thorny dilemma of whether to crack down on unpermitted construction — thus hindering a source of housing stock that is at least within reach for lower-income residents — look the other way, or "legalize" the units in an effort to mitigate potential fire hazards or health risks. Tang told us one of the greatest concerns named by Sunset residents is the increasing cost of living in San Francisco; she's even open to accepting a little more housing density in her district to deal with the issue.