A band of sisters
As Sleater-Kinney, Destiny's Child, and le Tigre bid farewell, an ex-all-girl punk band member wonders, where have all the music-making women gone?

kimberly@sfbg.com

Cast your eyes on the Billboard chart and it seems like summer 2006 will go down in history as the season of the Latin diva, with Nelly Furtado doffing a soft-focus folkie-cutie image by declaring herself "Promiscuous" and Shakira holding on to the promise of, well, that crazy, sexy, but not quite cool chest move she's close to trademarked via "Hips Don't Lie." Rihanna and Christina Aguilera brought up the rear of the Billboard Hot 100 singles chart last week — solo singers all. But with the on-again, off-again slow fade of Destiny's Child, the imminent demise of the explicitly feminist Sleater-Kinney, and the earlier evaporation of the even more didactic le Tigre, one has to wonder, what has happened to all-girl groups?

Was it a gimmick? Did Newsweek and Seventeen leach riot grrrl's genuine grassroots movement of its "authenticity" and power? Was Sarah McLachlan lame? Was Courtney Love insane? Perhaps the answer is on today's pop charts, where the sole "girl group" — if you don't count the manly guest MC appearances — is the frankly faux Pussycat Dolls, a sorry excuse for women's empowerment if there ever was one.

A D V E R T I S E M E N T


Their ’90s counterparts the Spice Girls baldly appropriated "girl power" as their own marketing slogan, but at least they gave 30-second-commercial-break lip service to the notion.

The scarcity of all-female bands — particularly the variety whose women do more than simply lip-synch on video — has perhaps spread to supposedly more progressive spheres. Erase Errata bassist-vocalist Ellie Erickson notes that when the band recently played Chicago's Intonation Music Festival, she was shocked to discover that their all-female trio made up almost half the total number of women performing among about 50 artists. Even at a more down-low, underground gathering like last month’s End Times Festival in Minneapolis, where Bay Area bands dominated, only one all-girl band, T.I.T.S., made the cut, observes the band's guitarist, Kim West. "When we were in Minneapolis there were so many girls who came up to us and were, like, 'This is so awesome! There are no all-girl bands here and it's so rare to see this,’” she recalls.

Girl groups do persist: the news-making, stand-taking, chops-wielding Dixie Chicks among them. But for every Chicks there's a Donnas, now off Atlantic after the Bay Area–bred band's second major-label release stumbled at takeoff. Is Dixie Chicks credibility forthcoming for commercial girl bands like Lillix, the Like, and Kittie? Some might argue that feminism's gains in the ’70s and ’80s — which led to the blossoming of all-female groups from TLC to Babes in Toyland, Vanity 6 to L7, and Fannypack to Bikini Kill — have led to a postfeminist moment in which strongly female-identified artists are ghettoized or otherwise relegated to the zone of erotic fantasy (e.g., Pussycat Dolls). Gone are the days when Rolling Stone touted the "Women of Rock" in their 1997 30th anniversary issue and Lilith Fair brought female singer-songwriters to every cranny of the nation.

"I think that with the demise of Sleater-Kinney and Le Tigre, it's a very sad time for girl groups," e-mails Evelyn McDonnell, Miami Herald pop culture writer and coauthor of Rock She Wrote. "It seems like the end of the ’90s women in rock era, an era that unfortunately left fewer marks than we hoped it would 15 years ago."

Radio's ...

Read more... Page: 1 | 2 | 3

( 14 comments | Comment on this article )
placenta on Wednesday, July 19, 2006 at 08:52 AM
No girl bands? What City are you living in? Our band, Placenta, played to 50,000 people at the Dyke March last month! We've also recently played at 924 Gilman, the Black Cat (in Penngrove), Kimo's, and we're playing at the Starry Plough (Berkeley), Annie's Social Club (SF) and the Stork Club (Oakland) in August. We've been on the cover of USA Today, in articles in The Chicago Tribune, the Wall Street Journal, the Italian Marie-Claire, The Oakland Tribune, the San Jose Mercury News, The SF Chronical, etc. etc. etc.

C'mon Guardian, why not go out to the clubs? You'd see that, rather than a disappearing girl band scene, there's a burgeoning home-grown girl band scene!

Not just Placenta, but there are the B-Cups, Sistas in the Pit, Coal Pitts Wash, Wire Graffiti, The Double D's, Retching Red, the Yes-Go's, Debra Knox, Zeparella, Whoreigner, etc. etc. etc. Any night that there are people playing in clubs in the Bay Area, there are girl bands playing in clubs in the Bay Area!

Perhaps, what really needs to happen is for this local paper to SUPPORT girl bands, to review our shows and CDs, and to get the word out that CHICKS ROCK!!!
mattt317 on Friday, July 21, 2006 at 01:23 PM
Correct me if I'm wrong, but at one point, didn't Erase Errata have a KICK Ass Dude in their band?

TIT's rocked 12 G's at last years Mission Creek Fest.... a show dedicated to the awesome Tom Cruise!

If Cibo Matto reads this, regroup, please....matt

friendswithbenefits on Friday, July 21, 2006 at 02:13 PM
Also, let's not forget Girl Band, who also call SF their home!
friendswithbenefits on Friday, July 21, 2006 at 02:15 PM
Also, let's not forget Girl Band, who also call SF their home!
friendswithbenefits on Friday, July 21, 2006 at 02:16 PM
Just found out Girl Band are having their cd release party tomorrow at Elbo Room, 10 pm. Check it out Guardian!
friendswithbenefits on Friday, July 21, 2006 at 02:18 PM
Just found out Girl Band are having their cd release party tomorrow at Elbo Room, 10 pm. Check it out Guardian!
skrufi on Friday, July 21, 2006 at 02:34 PM
What a funny article! The Bay Area is so chock full of girl bands! In fact, check out Girl Band here:

[link]

They'll be playing Saturday night at the Elbo Room (and they've never had a male member)
shoister on Saturday, July 22, 2006 at 09:16 AM
Uncharacteristically chuckle-headed writing from Kimberly Chun who should know perfectly well how many women are making music... especially in the "more progessive spheres". There were so many ways to justify one's desire to put Erase Errata on the cover (hey, whatever works), so I can't understand why it was done in a manner so offputting to all the women actually working in the field right now.

Try the womantis list at [link] for one of many tips of of the iceberg.

sheesh.
wholphin on Saturday, July 22, 2006 at 10:23 PM
Just because you can play at a number of small queer-friendly venues in the progressive Bay Area doesn't mean that Kimberly Chun is somehow missing out on the revolution. How well received would your band "Placenta" (or most any other bay area girl band) be at a big event that isn't aimed directly to the tastes of feminists & dykes?

I don't know how so many people could read this and think "Kimberly Chun thinks there aren't any girl bands in SF. I'd better set her straight!" It makes me a little bit sad.

This article was right on.

p.s.

EE had a male member very briefly, but I guess its kind of a secret.
shoister on Sunday, July 23, 2006 at 10:12 AM
OK, putting aside the fact that SFBG is *presenting* Erase Errata real soon now, so it behooves it to further diminish the line between advertising and editorial...

It seems the article is lamenting the demise of a certain opportunity for women musicians, but that is largely bound up in the economics of the industry, and, perhaps to a lesser extent, the social conservatism that Kimberly points out.

But what if your creative objective is *not* MTV airplay? I think there's an abundance of great music just outside the difficult environment of the industry. The reluctance of artists to engage with the industry, or to take on the risk and reward of creating alternatives to it, is just another day of DIY.
kimberly_chun on Monday, July 24, 2006 at 01:08 PM
Hey all,

Yeah, I'm all too familiar with how many women make music here - the Husbands and many others unmentioned but somewhat ineptly covered by the "among them" reference at the end of that short list of local bands. I guess that's why I agree with Kim West that this area is something of a hotbed for all-female bands. I suspect more than Olympia, Portland, or any other seething city of lady musicians/artists.

I know it seems somewhat nit-picky to say too that I wanted to discuss ALL-WOMEN bands and I'm sad that I ran out of space (but then it's really a book-length topic, honestly) before I could really get into why this mode of music making is still radical. Why it still might MATTER. Why there was such a stir among certain circles when a man (Archie, who I mentioned in the other story associated with this one), joined Erase Errata.

I hope the article poses enough questions and touches on a few of these topics to trigger more debate.

BTW I find it really thrilling that so many people have commented on this piece so far - and inspiring to read all the emails I've received for the pieces - from Chicks on Speed and others... This idea, this form of music production, "chicks rocking" really DOES have deep meaning to people. Beyond dumb slogans like, er, well take your pick. I find it all remarkable - even if most media outlets probably don't think this is a "story" (maybe some people wonder too - why am I writing about this when there are so many all-women bands around. I'd say, maybe because they're taken for granted, maybe because I wonder if their presence has been leached of meaning, whether the political conotations have left the building?). I also found myself really wanting to start another band with other girls as I put the piece togther.

P.S. For those who suspect an advertising-editorial tie-in between our Erase Errata coverage and them playing our Best of the Bay Party - there's no such thing apart from the fact that I noticed that they had joined the lineup a week or so ago. This story was in the works for longer than that. So, sorry, no sinister grand plan/conspiracy there...



CHIXPACK_666 on Tuesday, August 15, 2006 at 02:31 PM
Hola!

CHIX!

This is I-lean from SF Chix-Pack...

There IS a shortage on ALL CHICK Bands and has been for god damn ever!

If we could all work together this issue/dilema could move on! It is still a MALE-Dominated music scene.

We need to be self-sufficient to make a radical difference!

Woman Run....Sound Engineers...Booking Agents...Managers...Our own CD Labels...Our own Tour Busses.....Our own COLLABORATION!

Bitches always fightin bitches instead of working together! How many woman through time are known for their playing abilities?

Now we have this huge trend of all CHICK Cover Bands that is NOT making this crisis any better!

I do understand getting paid to play is as important.

What better way than to play Male bands music....

Check out CHIX-PACK at:

[link]

CHIX-PACK members can be found A LOT of places:

San Francisco, Los Angeles, Tahoe, Oakland, Canada,Texas,Seattle,Portland,Bolinas,Petaluma,Australia, Japan..CHIX-PACK....CHIX WITH A PACT!!!!!!!!

CHIXPACK_666 on Tuesday, August 15, 2006 at 02:47 PM
Oh yeah!

Kimberly ....Let's JAM!
mouthwaterer on Thursday, December 7, 2006 at 09:30 PM
You should also check out Los Angeles based rock band Ze Auto Parts ([link]). Although I think they also had a male drummer for some time, but they are quite a female force to be reckoned with. Though not based in SF they are no strangers, and one of their members is an SF native.

Comment on: A band of sisters

In order to comment on an article, you must Log In.

SFBG Classifieds