The straight story on the armory
What makes the Kink.com case different

The sale of the former National Guard armory on Mission Street has caused a flurry of concern about the plans for the site of the new owner and developer, Kink.com. Most of the columns and editorials in the San Francisco Chronicle, Examiner, and BeyondChron.com have been reactionary and politically opportunistic. It has given the cheerleaders of runaway market-rate development a new reason to knock affordable housing advocates in general and the Mission Anti-Displacement Coalition in particular.

For the past six years, MAC, with the participation of hundreds of Mission District residents, has been developing a vision for the neighborhood, called the People's Plan, which confronts the gentrification pressures of new development and sets out policies for a healthy, sustainable community. Our approach is not that of knee-jerk NIMBYs mindlessly opposing any proposed change in our community. We are in favor of affordable housing, good-paying jobs for immigrants and working-class families, and sustainable economic development.

However, immediately after the Kink.com story broke, writers such as Ken Garcia blamed MAC for directly causing the sale to what other papers are calling a "porn production company.

A D V E R T I S E M E N T


" It's true that MAC has opposed the previous three development proposals, but the developers themselves, responding to the ups and downs of the market, ultimately dropped the projects for financial reasons. Here's a brief review:

In 2000 a multimedia office complex proposal was approved by the Planning Department and later dropped. The armory was then going to be a server farm. The server farm was approved by the Planning Department again (contrary to what Garcia has written), but the company went under. A local financier retained control and proposed an outlandish and financially risky housing proposal.

The luxury housing proposal went into the planning process, and an environmental review had begun, but instead, the owner sold the site to Kink.com

MAC didn't know the owner was secretly negotiating the sale of the armory. Had the financiers been honest with the community, perhaps the city or some other entity could have come forward and put the armory to better use. But at this point, the sale of the armory is complete, and there's no further process necessary for the new owners to set up shop. That means it's difficult for the community or city to stop the proposed use.

Now the community finds itself responding to this purchase and to opportunists who are taking advantage of this situation to use the current plan as a wedge issue to attack MAC and other affordable housing activists who have had concerns about high-end market-rate housing development in the Mission. The Mission is both the heart of the Latino community in San Francisco and home to other communities. For a healthy and sustainable community, a measuring stick for a development project is whether it will lead to displacement of residents and community-serving businesses and contribute to gentrification.

MAC will continue to fight for equitable development through the People's Plan and the Mission rezoning process and will continue to challenge all projects that have the potential to negatively impact our community. *

Eric Quezada and Nick Pagoulatos

Eric Quezada and Nick Pagoulatos are Mission Anti-Displacement ...

Read more... Page: 1 | 2

( 5 comments | Comment on this article )
markshervey on Wednesday, February 7, 2007 at 11:05 AM
In the future, it might be a good idea to mention who MAC and NIMBY are. I assume NIMBY is Mayor Gavin Newsom. Not sure who MAC is.

Anyway, the new angle and information on this situation is appreciated.

Thanks,

Mark
Burly on Wednesday, February 7, 2007 at 11:20 AM
Well, it may be the "straight story" from the MAC perspective, but it certainly isn't the whole story. The armory has been vacant for 37 years. The MAC should probably thank Kink.com for preventing another 37 years of vacancy and decay. I find it hard to believe that a massive fortress with no windows would be a good place for "low cost housing", sounds more like affordable prison cells. The place is the definition of "white elephant", which is probably why it has never been developed.
mizshan on Wednesday, February 7, 2007 at 05:58 PM
Burly, you're missing the point too, which is NOT that affordable housing is the best use of the Armory (they didn't say that). The point is that the community has every right to organize to influence developers so that key sites are used in ways that don't harm the neighborhood.

Kink.com won't harm the neighborhood the way previous proposals for the site - that MAC fought- would have, IMHO. (oh and that stands for In My Humble Opinion, markshervey).
Nicohey on Friday, February 9, 2007 at 01:41 PM
As a mission resident, I would be more heartened if associations like MAC, would be concerned about the rampant homeless, drug users, shootings (at 16th and mission), and prostitution in the neighborhood than about a company that is going to do its business behind closed doors. The authors say that this isn't a NIMBY reaction, that in fact is exactly what it is as they have BLOCKED everything that has tried to go into that building. Regardless of the developers MAC has a direct responsibility for that building being empty for the past 37 years. To claim otherwise is an outright lie by the authors. At some point groups like MAC have to wake up and see that the path they are on makes them advocates for the many unsafe aspects to living in the Mission. But hey, that is probably asking too much.
paula1402 on Wednesday, March 7, 2007 at 05:35 PM
Isn't MAC forgetting something? The Mission may be Latino now, but before that it was home to the Irish immigrants.

City guidlines require every new development to include affordable housing - lets not force out those with money to spend and paying property taxes in order to accommodate those who don't...

Comment on: The straight story on the armory

In order to comment on an article, you must Log In.

SFBG Classifieds