December 3 , 2003 (Vol. 38, No. 10)

noise.

Editor: Kimberly Chun
Art director: Lori Spears
Noise logo & cover designer: J. Fish
Music accounts executive: Chris Owen

Into Africa

By Hua Hsu

'THEY THINK IT'S all jungles and huts," a local DJ from Johannesburg, South Africa, said with a laugh. The shock of travel nowadays is usually one of recognition. Go nearly anywhere on the planet and you'll likely find some familiar vestige of the Western comforts you thought you'd left behind. Thousands of miles away, listening to stories of famous rappers paying awkward visits to the motherland, I rediscovered some of the nasty complexities of being American: you speak with privilege, even if you reject it; the things you say travel, even if they aren't thought out. Others follow your cultural lead, even if your stuff is wack.

When scholar Edward Said passed earlier this year, I was making preparations for a trip to South Africa to observe an international academy for DJs and producers. The night before I left, I revisited "Traveling Theories," his 1983 essay more or less concerned with what kinds of stories, knowledge, or ideas are produced when one travels. I fell asleep wondering what ideas I would acquire in the next two weeks.

There are stories going around Johannesburg and Cape Town about Ja Rule. Earlier this year, Ja (who's still very popular in other parts of the world) trekked to the mother continent for some concerts. The highlights – some exaggerated, some accurate – include Ja mistaking Soweto for a bangin' club he wanted to check out, Ja accusing South African blacks of not being tough enough, and Ja's cronies roughing up a local DJ for dropping a 50 Cent song in his presence.

The point of conveying this story isn't to poke fun at Ja's ignorance – though, if you want to include his ambassadorial offenses with his long list of musical ones, be my guest. The problem here was his arrogance – the kind of fuck-you-pay-me self-assurance that comes with the validation of sales and riches. It's interesting how the affinities you imagine in your head look when you travel. Ja assumed Africa would feel him unconditionally, and he wasn't the only one: agit-rappers Dead Prez made a similar sojourn, and though they were far more respectful of the conditions of black life there and, as a result, far more loved, they also crashed the nation's tenuous postapartheid landscape with their clunky, us-versus-them moralizing.

But Dead Prez's politics at least allowed something for the kids to sink their teeth into. It's troubling enough to see the trickle-down effect of hip-hop materialism in the United States. It's downright depressing to see it ripple outward to the poor cities globalization left behind. The theatrics and play of Jay-Z don't travel as well as the swagger, the ice, and the Reeboks. Hip-hop's obsession with its own success may be excused as showy neighborhood pride here, but it's as good as imperialism over there, anywhere.

But the music of those modest videos was heartening. Local musicians say South Africa's Kwaito scene is on the cusp of big things. It's a uniquely local blend of the area's two favorite imports, house and hip-hop, and many of those whom American hip-hop lost have turned to Kwaito. They've picked through the hip-hop blueprint for the parts that translate – self-worth, beats – and left behind the bits that don't. Ditto the little scenes around the world no longer interested in approval from the American specter: broken beat, garage, hip-life (highlife plus hip-hop), etc. For these kids, out of the limelight (for now) but verging on something really breathtaking, hip-hop has become a point of departure rather than the destination.

The flight back to New York City was intolerably long. At home nothing had changed: Jay-Z's lackluster love-me-or-fuck-you Black Album was winning hearts and minds. I looked around this unsatisfying landscape; it never seemed so rife with possibilities.

Ten more things I rediscovered

Stone Roses, The Stone Roses (Silvertone)

Eddie Kendricks, People ... Hold On (Motown)

Roy Davis Jr., "I'm Here to Spread Love" (Strictly Rhythm)

Donny Hathaway, Live (Atlantic)

Jungle Brothers, Straight out the Jungle (Warlock)

Hall and Oates, "I Can't Go for That (No Can Do)" (RCA)

Ray Barretto, "Acid" (Fania)

Pastels, "Nothing to Be Done" (Homestead)

Nico, Chelsea Girl (Polydor)

Luomo, Vocal City (Force Tracks)

Last Month's Issue
last month's noise.