Today the Planning Commission holds a hearing about Lennar's massive development plan for Candlestick and Hunters Point Shipyard, a plan the Guardian has been critically tracking for years, but the Mayor's Office and a non-profit called the Center for Creative Land Recycling have been busily promoting (check out the above video clip). But one thing they won't be talking about is the Alternatives For Study that Arc Ecology proposed, Bionic developed and Urban Strategies reviewed two years ago, in an effort to improve the developer's otherwise Foster City-like vision for the heart of District 10 in the city's southeast sector.
And that's ironic, because the AFS proposal just received an honor award.(Scroll to bottom of AFS proposal link to see award.)
Saul Bloom, Arc Ecology's excutive director, explains why Bionic got the award, and who was involved in the AFS proposal.
"Bionic is our landscape architectural and planning consultant," Bloom said. "We do the conceptual planning and they do the detail, design and associated planning work. So in AFS, I worked with Bionic to develop the land use plans and analysis. I conceptualized where they would put various features of the plan, they either agreed, offered alternatives, or argued why I didn't know what I was talking about. It was then my decision as to what went forward to the draft document.Once the draft document was produced Eve Bach [recently deceased], Ruth Gravanis, Arthur Feinstein, Junious and Anne from Urban Strategies and a number of other folks reviewed the materials and edited text. Bionic then finalized the design, I gave final approval and the document was published. As such it really was a team planning effort.However because Bionic is the landscape architecture firm - they get the fame. Because of Arc's karma we get the infamy."
So, is it fair to say that none of the AFS proposal are in the plan that will be the subject of today's hearing, which promises to focus on the below-market rate housing plan, the community benefits plan, workforce development and local hiring policies?
"Not entirely," Bloom quipped. "They have been integrated into the study in order to reject them."
Most Commented On
- 15 - 20 new planners? - December 5, 2013
- It is often said that it is suffering that creates great art. - December 5, 2013
- Cage Match - December 5, 2013
- You clearly need to understand the SFBG hierarchy of needs. - December 5, 2013
- Its true, I read it on the - December 5, 2013
- Artists are doing what they love to do. - December 5, 2013
- So affordability has nothing to do with money? - December 5, 2013
- We don't want to be recruited into any movement that a dick - December 5, 2013
- Srill awaiting ANSWERS and VIDEOS from Police Dept and Chief - December 5, 2013
- Financial support is way different - December 5, 2013