Occupy Oakland inmates at Santa Rita attacked- developing story

Santa Rita jail in Dublin, CA


In the aftermath of the mass arrests of Occupy Oakland protesters-- and whoever else happend to be on the wrong street at the wrong time-- on Jan. 28 in Oakland, there have been loads of reports and rumors about brutality inflicted on those arrested. Most of those arrested were held in Santa Rita jail.

My observations:

I spent 20 hours in jail, and I saw some cruel treatment. I saw people suffering after being denied medication. I saw people with allergies to the food that was provided refused any substitute and unable to eat, sometimes for more than 24 hours. I saw people crammed into holding cells meant for groups a third their size, so that some people had to remain standing, sometimes for more than 24 hours. As many arrestees were wearing clothing coated in tear gas and pepper spray, those chemicals continued to waft through cells and affect all present.


I have reports directly from sources of arrested occupiers being beat up in jail with police batons. At least 20 people were ziptied, meaning their hands were cuffed behind their backs-- and more often than not, if they happen to be cuffed too tightly and their hands go numb and even blue, police won't loosen them-- for more than eight hours. I know that some people who were denied access to a restroom ended up sitting in their own vomit and urine for at least four hours in some cases.

UPDATE Another report from Joshua Clover, a professor of English at UC Davis, who was released Monday night, :
"I was held for 53 hours for a misdemeanor charge which every single person here, and there, knows will never be brought, and indeed which will be met with a class action suit for wrongful arrest that the city of Oakland will be compelled to settle. I have a perforated peptic ulcer. Early on in the stay I requested non—prescription care — liquid antacid, which the jail keeps on hand — when I began to have an ulcer attack, which is to say, when I began to bleed internally. I was not given such care until an attorney was able to intervene by phone many hours later. I received one capful, which was mildly effective for about three hours. Further requests were ignored. As many will know, a bleeding ulcer attack is both painful and potentially fatal"

UPDATE When I questioned Alameda County Sheriff's Department Public Information Officer Sergeant JD Nelson about this, he responded that "[Clover] was obviously seen by a medical person, and they said that was enough medicine."

But accoridng to Clover, via an email, "The one time that I received medication, a deputy came to the cell door accompanied by someone who may have been a nurse, holding a capful of antacid. I asked for more but was not given it." And was Clover seen by a medical professional to determine the correct amount of medication? He says, "Definitely not."

Also according to Clover, "Food was often not provided for periods of up to 14 hours. For a long period I shared a cell with 27 other people; it was about ten by ten feet. For a period I was in a cell labeled 'Maximum Occupancy: Two.' There were ten of us, three very sick. We stood. One of the people slumped over on the toilet, that being the alternative to standing."


"Three people I know were denied medication for HIV infections while being held for multiple days, which is a life-threatening choice made by the county"

"two women were denied anti-depressants that they had with them when they went to jail"

UPDATE According to an anonymous source, "My 12x12 cell had 28 people. There was a toilet, a concrete bench, and enough hard floor space for three or four of us to sleep at a time. A girl in the cell across from ours told the guards she needed Lexapro or she would go into withdrawl. They ignored the request. One of my cellmates was HIV-positive. When I last saw him at 2 a.m. on Monday morning he had not yet been given his medications. As I exited the jail I saw a woman who had just been released lying on the floor. She was having a seizure and being tended to by a couple of firemen."

UPDATE From Alyssa Eisenberg, who has multiple sclerosis:
"I take my medication at least twice a day...without it, the pain is, everything kind of goes numb and tightens up. Somtimes I can't even see without it. When  had to sign the booking form about noon i couldn't even see it, my vision was so blurry...I was told they don't give meds to people that are going to be cited and released, only to people that are going to stay and get charged."

Unconfirmed reports:

Daily Kos quotes an anonymous source who reports that "prisoners from the Oakland Commune were being denied medications (some had seizures) while the guards said they didnt care if they died. Some people were brutally beaten. The put tear gas in the vents of my cell twice."
According to Occupy Oakland media spokesperson Omar Yassin, a report that someone was tear gassed in the jail's hallway is likely credible.

Then there's the peolpe who were injured during the protests Jan. 28. Also according to Yassin:

At least a dozen people had welts on their faces or bodies from being beaten by clubs or shot with rubber bullets. One woman was shot in both arms with rubber bullet; one man was shot in the face with rubber bullets while holding a video camera to document the events. Several protesters were shoved to the ground and received wounds on their faces while being arrested. Police raised their rubber-bullet rifles to the faces of protesters throughout the day, threatening attacks-- a rubber bullet to the face can cause brain damage and blindness.


A spokesperson for the Alameda County Sheriff's Department refused to comment, although she did say that they've "been bombarded with calls about this all day." Shocker.

UPDATE According to Alameda County Sheriff's Department Public Information Officer Sergeant JD Nelson, no complaints of mistreatment at Santa Rita have been filed.

Nelson said that peanut butter was made avaliable to vegans those allergic to meat, in direct contrast to what I witnessed in jail.

In response to reports that some detainees were held on buses in the Santa Rita parking lot for up to eight hours, during which time they were refused bathroom access and in some cases made to sit in their own urine and vomit, Nelson said that "Generally when they come to the jail the buses are unloaded fairly quickly. Obviously some people are going to go first, some last."

He told me that detainees were denied medication because "We do we allow them to take their medication in jail. People will try to smuggle stuff in."

When asked about reported beating in jail, Nelson replied, "I haven't gotten any reports of any skirmishes between officers and those arrested. We would report it if  there was any use of force,"

According to Nelson, the Alameda County Sheriff's Office has video footage of all of the areas in the jail where arrestees were held, and, unless there was a lawsuit preventing its release, he would make the footage available to me soon. For now he said, "I don't even know if they've been developed." (Is this 1984? Not in the Orwellian sense. In the technology sense.)

More on this soon. Send me information that you have, yael@sfbg.com


Did any of you run into sgt Armstrong, he's one of the worst he a total bully and mis use his standing to abuse and get away with it. My son name is Mitchell Comeaux, he was beaten at the hands of this man and others. The report says two people restrained him but the video clearly shows more and Armstrong grabbing my son by the back of head while he's handcuffed pulling him forward into his knee. The video show my son being beat while handcuffed. You may asked what a stared this, all he did was ask to be put in his cell he had been in a holding cell for 24hr and room was running out from there Asshole oops Armstrong attacked. Santa Rita hid my son from me, wrong visiting days, after they whipped him wouldn't tell me his bail kept saying he didn't have one, when he did. Court dates my God next to impossible to get every court date,place and time was wrong. So I had 5 other people call and get this we all got different information. The only way I got the chance to see my child, I went to the courthouse everyday and stayed all day until close. On the day I saw my son I was told 2:00 my son was seen at 9:36am. My son face was swollen eyes black he had a bad limp, matter fact his face was busted open. And he still hold that scar and will for the rest of his life. As he was on the cold concrete floor short ripped off he was had an asthma attack and asked someone to get his inhaler ffrom his pocket what they do nothin,Armstrong and gang stood and watched as this 19yr old couldn't breathe, and Armstrong was trifling,low down,sad,sadistic,evil,hate filled,bitter just a sorry human being walking around stealing oxygen looked down on him and said " the lil nigga shit his self". Little he is, he's 5'2 104lbs a nigga he's not. The only niggas that day was the ones on duty in uniform. R.ARMSTONG and GANG. Nigga is a personality not a nationality. Now due to this my son has a felony for getting assaulted by someone in uniform. We have to realize uniforms come off and underneath there's people who do wrong just as we do. They need to stand accountable for their actions and the cover ups need to stop. Everybody should be fired and replaced.they know wants going on. Their turning their heads or they are going along with it. Either way something needs to be done. An investigation needs to be held. I contacted the news Bout this I guess now it may get some attention.

Posted by Francheska slay on Nov. 13, 2012 @ 9:03 am

Stop your pathetic whining and put on some big boy pants. You get arrested for a crime, then birch about your lack of customer service. If you have health problems, don't put yourself in A situation that will have a negative effect on your health. Then you complain that the tax payer supported meds are good enough for you. Go tell someone else your so called crisis that you had to suffer through, please.

Posted by Guest on Feb. 23, 2013 @ 8:41 am

Hi, thanks for sharing

Posted by card on Apr. 11, 2013 @ 7:20 am

Related articles

  • After the tear gas clears

    What are the lessons from the conflicts of the latest Occupy Oakland action?

  • Inside the Occupy Oakland protest

  • OccupyOakland vigil dismantled, 11 arrested

  • Also from this author

  • Privatization of public housing

    Many residents feel they're moving from the frying pan of Housing Authority control into the fire of developer and nonprofit management

  • Homeless for the holidays

    Changing demographics in the Bayview complicate city efforts to open a shelter there

  • Betting on Graton

    Newest casino targeting Bay Area residents promises to share the wealth with workers and people of color