23 February 1999
DATELINE -- Oakland, Calif.
Organic is as organic does
A campaign to clean up the organic farm.
Larry Comras knows his fruits. He also knows his vegetables, meats, and even
condiments. All of which, he insists, must be organic or else they "don't
go in my kitchen."
Comras, the single father of two young girls, is a regular shopper at the
Wild Oats Co-Op in Oakland, Calif. Once a week, the 43-year-old contractor
takes his two kids on a shopping adventure to the local natural foods
store.
Over the years, the Comras family has used these outings as occasions to
learn about the natural world and to understand how food gets from the
fields to the table. But these days, Comras is teaching 8 year-old
Cassandra and 5 year-old Calliope to thumb their noses at the colorful
cornucopia of fresh produce inside Green Hills.
"Dad says the farmers are mean to workers, and we have to make them stop,"
says Cassandra, a third grader at Emma Willard Elementary School. Her
father simultaneously blushes and smiles. "Not every farmer is mean,"
Comras gently corrects his daughter, "but some don't treat the people who
work for them very well."
Labor isn't a typical topic of conversation for the Comras family. Between
soccer practice and piano lessons, there's seldom mention of anything more
serious than a name calling incident at school or whether Calliope is
getting a Furby for her birthday. In fact, Comras considers himself a
"middle-of-the-road conservative," but allows that he has a "soft spot" for
organic goods.
It was his interest in health food that first drew Comras to the debate
surrounding government-imposed standards for the labeling of organic foods.
Last year the National Organic Standards Board, a federally appointed
agency, announced guidelines that would allow gene-modified, irradiated or
sludge-fertilized crops to be marketed as "USDA Organic." Comras was one
of the millions of organic enthusiasts who circulated petitions and wrote
letters protesting the new policy. "I'm not a proactive kind of guy,"
admits Comras, "but I'm very involved with what my family eats."
In the end, the proposed guidelines were amended, but there remained a
number of controversial elements -- the failure to address the use of
antibiotics, nonorganic feed, and long-term confinement of animals in the
production of organic meat. Ironically, it was the omission of standards
ensuring the quality of life of chickens and cows which extended the debate
to a discussion of farm labor conditions.
"Organic foods are the growth industry for the next century," predicts
Scott Figgins, coordinator of Healthy Food Workers, the organization
spearheading the latest campaign to modify the National Organic Standards
Board labeling policies. "It's a $4 billion a year industry," adds Figgins,
"but it's fueled by hundreds of thousands of people working in unsanitary
and unsafe conditions."
Those "unsanitary and unsafe conditions" are the focus of Healthy Food
Workers' efforts to clean up working conditions in the organic food
industry. Figgins launched his crusade in 1996, when a young girl died
after ingesting an unpasteurized Odwalla juice drink tainted with the
deadly E.coli bacteria. The Odwalla scare, which resulted in several hospitalizations and a massive product recall, was ultimately linked to traces of fecal matter on the apples used to make the contaminated organic
juice drink.
Epidemiologists eventually faulted unsanitary agriculture industry
practices, namely the routine denial of bathroom breaks and facilities to
farm laborers. In the Odwalla incident, it was most likely workers unable
to wash their hands who introduced the E.coli bacteria to the affected
apple harvest.
While advocates and industry leaders were debating whether or not
genetically-engineered foods should receive the "organic" seal of approval,
Figgins was already working on incorporating the labor component of the
harvest process into the certification guidelines.
"As consumers of organic foods we pay a premium for the quality and purity
of what we eat," Figgins explains. "If we're talking about organic meats,
we worry about the confinement of animals and their treatment. When we
worry about produce, we have to think about the confinement of workers and
their treatment."
Figgins has taken that formulation on the road. Every weekend and some
weekday afternoons, Healthy Food Workers volunteers distribute leaflets to
shoppers at farmers markets and natural foods stores throughout Northern
California. The flyers, which contain such friendly catch phrases as
"organic begins with the hand that picks the fruit that feeds you," appear
to be changing the way consumers shop.
As the Comras family steers their cart through the produce aisles of the
Wild Oats Co-Op, Cassandra and Calliope ask their dad which farm stickers
are "green" and which are "mean." By the end of their circuit, they survey
the contents of their cart. "A little lighter than usual," Comras remarks,
"but I don't think the girls will miss the spicy salad mix."
The South to the Future World Wide Wire Service is a weekly feed of technology and media news commentary and satire published by the San Francisco Bay Guardian. Quotations attributed to public figures who are satirized are often true, but sometimes invented. Some fictional statements may, in fact, be true. Any other use of real names is accidental and coincidental. Editorial questions may be sent to John
Paczkowski.