19 April 1999
DATELINE--Los Angeles
PETA protests pet prozac
Whitney Combs, a professional dog walker, is behind bars.
Because Combs' offense involved material damages in the neighborhood of
$10,000, she will have to spend the next three weeks in a Los Angeles
County jail while awaiting arraignment on felony charges. She shares her
cramped 8 by 12 foot cell with a female gang member who was arrested for
assault. Combs says she is having difficulty sleeping and cries for several
hours each night.
Yet it is not so much her own fate which saddens Combs as that of her
"fellow" animals. "I may be in a concrete jail," she asserts, "but the
animals I tried to help are in a far worse prison."
Last week Combs and a male companion were apprehended after attempting to
steal three of her charges: a two year-old Norfolk Terrier, a six year-old
Rottweiler, and a 3 year-old Papillon. In a statement made to police
shortly after her arrest, the dogwalker says she was forced to take custody
of the animals when she detected signs of abuse.
However the abuse Combs claims to have discovered was not physical. In
fact, it may not even be considered abuse under current law. According to
the 26 year-old petcare worker, the animals were suffering because they
were being drugged against their will. The dogs' owners and local
authorities did not agree.
But what might have ended as a bizarre contract dispute between Combs and
her clients has instead become the flashpoint of a national campaign to ban
the prescription of mood-altering drugs for companion animals. Earlier this
week, the animal-rights organization People for the Ethical Treatment of
Animals offered to foot the bill for the legal representation of Combs and
her co-defendant.
PETA's involvement in Combs' legal defense is the latest volley in what has
already become a hot debate within the animal right's community. Some
activists believe that using antidepressant or antianxiety drugs such as
Prozac or Xanax as a remedy for pet-related problems is unethical. Others
contend that using medical solutions to alleviate behavioral problems is in
the best interest of pets as well as their owners.
Richard Taber, a 62 year-old veterinarian in Long Beach, says he has had
great success prescribing Novartis AG's Clomicalm to pets that suffer from
separation anxiety. Taber also relies upon a drug called Anipryl to treat
senility in dogs. "For pet owners who work away from home," explains Taber,
"there is often little else they can do to alleviate the suffering of their
lonely pets." Loneliness often leads to serious behavioral problems like
increased vocalization (barking), hypersalivation, and inappropriate
elimination.
Taber is not alone in his use of prescription medications to help owners
deal with problem pets. Drug maker Pfizer Inc. estimates the U.S. retail
market for pet pharmaceuticals reached $2.6 billion last year, up 10% from
1997. Drugs for animals diagnosed with obsessive compulsive or cognitive
disorders, and even depression are all currently available.
Not all animal healthcare specialists share the enthusiasm for doggie
drugs. Alice McCandless is an animal behaviorist with the Orange County
Humane Society. She believes the rush to dose companion animals is a
symptom of greater societal problems. "If your environment is making your
pet sick," asserts McCandless, "you should be thinking about improving your
environment rather than distorting your pet's psyche."
PETA spokesperson Rahula Isackson takes an even stronger tack. "What's at
stake is more than proscribing Prozac for pets." Isackson wants to make the
Combs case a watershed moment in the fight against animal abuse. Says the
PETA official, "We need pet companions -- people -- to treat animals as
individuals with feelings, families, and friendships, not just as toys,
possessions,or commodities."
Rhetoric aside, old school veterinarians like Taber give little credence to
the notion that pets are actually worse off when receiving medication.
"We're talking about pets, here, not wild animals," argues Taber, "they've
been bred to complement human society. If their owners can benefit from
antidepressants why can't they?"
The South to the Future World Wide Wire Service is a weekly feed of technology and media news commentary and satire published by the San Francisco Bay Guardian. Quotations attributed to public figures who are satirized are often true, but sometimes invented. Some fictional statements may, in fact, be true. Any other use of real names is accidental and coincidental. Editorial questions may be sent to John
Paczkowski.